I chose the Audio Technica ATH-900xAD and have been very happy with it. Just a note on it though, it doesn't have a traditional adjustable head band. It has "wings" that sit on top of your head and you barely feel its on. Now, it fits me well, but others may dislike it.
I am looking for a headset that plugs into the 3.5mm jack on my PC which would be used mostly for gaming. The reviews I find are great, but they all have built in Mic's. I have a Blu Yeti which is fine, so I don't want one built into my headset. Wireless/Bluetooth isn't necessary either...