Gaming laptop ~$1600; hordes of questions

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the Tom's Guide community: where nearly two million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

cortillaen

Distinguished
May 26, 2011
6
0
18,510
So after spending plenty of time looking at parts and getting opinions here on what to put in a new desktop build, I learned that I will likely not have enough room for a desktop for at least one or two 7-month periods in the next 4 years. I really can't justify putting upwards of $1300 into a system (the remaining $300 was for monitor, keyboard, mouse, and traveling protection) that will be a pain to move around the country (very likely to happen a few times in the same time frame) and that I won't even be able to have with me for the better portion of a year. Ergo, time to look at laptops. Too bad they can't even scratch the performance of the lower-cost desktop build, but that's what one has to put up with when moving about becomes a way of life.

1.What is your Budget?
~$1600 (willing to go a couple hundred higher, but only for very substantial improvement)

2.What is the size of the laptop that you are considering?
17"

3.What screen resolution do you want?
Not picky, but the capacity for 1920x1080 would be nice

4.Do you need a portable or desktop replacement laptop?
Desktop replacement

5.How much battery life do you need?
Not an issue. This will almost always be used near an outlet.

6.Do you want to play games with your laptop? If so then please list the games that you want to with the settings that you want for these games. (Low,Medium or High)?
Starcraft 2, Mass Effect 3, Skyrim, Deus Ex Human Revolution, Shogun 2, etc. Medium or better settings

7.What other tasks do you want to do with your laptop?
Web surfing, web games, the usual office software, and watching movies (but HD is not necessary)

8.How much storage (H.D.D Capacity) do you need?
500Gb or more

9.If you are considering specific sites to buy from, please post their links.
Looking at Pro-Star and XoticPC right now for customizable performance without exceeding my price range, but any site that is reputable and has what I want at a good price is fine. Falcon Northwest and Origin were recommended to me, but I don't see anything there that would be affordable for me.
The two specific models I'm considering at the moment (open to others; these were just the two that seemed the best fit of features-to-cost of what I've seen) are:
MSI GT780DXR-446US from XoticPC - upgraded 12Gb 1600MHz RAM, removed second HDD, switched ODD to DVDRW/CDRW combo, clean OS install and recovery disc, and rushed assembly (1-4 days) for $1712 -$100MIR, free shipping, and the military discount (anyone know what it is? I'm still waiting on a reply from their supposedly 7 days a week live chat's "nobody's here; leave a message" thingy)
MSI GT780DX-406US from Pro-Star - only has the 1.5Gb 570M (waiting on a reply from them to see if they can put in the 3Gb instead), upgraded to 12Gb 1600MHz RAM, and priority assembly (1 day) for $1606 with no MIR, uncertain shipping, and no military discount that I can see.

10.How long do you want to keep your laptop?
About 4 years

11.What kind of Optical drive do you need? DVD ROM/Writer,Bluray ROM/Writer,Etc?
CDRW/DVDRW combo

12.Please tell us about the brands that you prefer to buy from them and the brands that you don't like and explain the reasons.
I don't trust Dell's quality. Other than that, no particular likes or dislikes.

13.What country do you live in?
USA

14.Please tell us any additional information if needed.
I'd really like to get something with the GTX 570M or better GPU. The 560M seems like it will start to choke on new games, even at low settings, before my expected 4 years of use are done, and I want to at least have new games playable on low settings up to that point. I'd like to keep the RAM at 1600MHz, and 12Gb would be nice (will settle for 8Gb, but most of the systems I've looked at have a minimal charge for the 4Gb step up, like $8 at the Pro-Star link above). If the system comes without an OS (with accompanying price drop, of course), that would be great, too, since I already have a Win7Pro disc on hand.

Questions: I doubt I'll ever be connecting to a really fast network anyway, so is there any point in upgrading from the basic 802.11 Wireless B/G/N wireless card?
How big of a difference would going from the GTX 570M 1.5Gb to the 3Gb version make?
How essential is a laptop cooler pad, and are either of the ones on the build pages above decent deals?
Why does it seem like all of the 17" laptops, especially the ones with GTX 570M or better GPUs, come with i7 processors as the base instead of a top-end i5? I know the i5-2500K (saw the 2550K on sale for $5 less this week, too) is considered the premier affordable gaming processor, so will a sub-$2000 gaming laptop actually benefit any from a more expensive i7?
Is buying the better dead-pixel protection worth it?
EDIT:
Forgot another question: Is getting the better thermal compounds worth it for a laptop?
 
I have both a laptop and desktop (2600k @ 4.8 Ghz and twin 1000 Mhz 560 Ti) and game happily on both of them. I use AutoCAD and a laptop is a necessity for field work....luckily, good AutoCAD boxes make good gaming boxes. And before anyone jumps in about using workstation cards, while AutoDesk makes rendering programs, AutoCAD itself is a vector graphics programs and runs excellently on Geforce cards.

For the past 6 years I have owned nothing but Clevo laptops. When I was looking back then at Alienware, Falcon Northwest, Sager, WidowPC, etc and figuring on sending $4k on one....I found a striking resemblance among all their offerings and the reason was, they were all made by Clevo distributors .....and the Clevo was 33% less expensive.

Prostar served me well for a few years but when the economy tanked, their service department went downhill fast. One laptop was returned 4 times and sent back because they could find nothing wrong with it. Another failure they claimed was broken because someone spilled something on it......that never happened.

So while I would still steer you to Clevo, I'd avoid ProStar as their service department is but a shadow of what it used to be.

With the 675M just hitting laptops now, I'd wait a few weeks for the 6xx series to penetrate further.

Dell dosn't make bad stuff, just horribly overpriced and loaded w/ bloatware.
 

Kiingzz

Honorable
Mar 27, 2012
39
0
10,590




Dell aren't overpriced at all in fact I believe they are one of the cheapest brands on the market today. Before you go and say "cheap and nasty" don't even bother. I bought an Ispiron 15R with i7 2670QM, 4GB RAM and Nvidia 525m gfx for $674 AU which is about $700 US, if that is horribly overpriced for a brand new laptop which is capable of many things then Biggie Smalls and Tupac Shakur are still alive. And I have seen most of the Dell range recently and it seems most of their laptops are fairly cheap considering their specs.