PokeMMO: Fan-Made MMORPG Based on Pokemon Games

Status
Not open for further replies.

jimmyjohnz

Honorable
May 14, 2012
20
0
10,560
0
[citation][nom]Shin-san[/nom]How long will this last before Nintendo takes it down[/citation]

It shouldn't be taken down as long as people obtain their ROMs legally. This should mean getting it off of their own Fire Red cartridge. If they get it from the various ROM sites out there, it's the user's risk, not the people who made the MMO mod.
 

jimmyjohnz

Honorable
May 14, 2012
20
0
10,560
0
[citation][nom]Shin-san[/nom]How long will this last before Nintendo takes it down[/citation]

It's on the person who downloads the ROM to own the physical copy of the game too, and with the physical copy, he/she owns the licence to use the game. Though I'm pretty sure to be completely legal you really need to rip the ROM off of the actual cartridge, but copyright laws aren't really black and white about it. Forgive me if I'm wrong about anything.
 

IndignantSkeptic

Distinguished
Apr 19, 2011
120
0
18,630
0
Yah who is going to know how to build the equipment to rip the ROM themselves? The whole thing is silly, of course they are going to download it from the internet. I wish Nintendo would just stop being silly and release all their games for PC finally.
 

nforce4max

Distinguished
Sep 9, 2009
516
0
18,960
8
[citation][nom]IndignantSkeptic[/nom]Yah who is going to know how to build the equipment to rip the ROM themselves? The whole thing is silly, of course they are going to download it from the internet. I wish Nintendo would just stop being silly and release all their games for PC finally.[/citation]

That is like Apple making their OSX available to be installed on any machine which will never happen.
 

NuclearShadow

Distinguished
Sep 20, 2007
670
0
18,940
1
Legally you can make a copy of a game but only from your exact copy. So if you had the means to take your actual game cartridge of Poke'mon and make the rom file that would be legal. Downloading someone else's copy whether or not you own the game is not.

Of course I don't think that any company including Nintendo has the moral right to object.
They make hardware incapable of playing legally made copies which should be just as equally against the law as it is intentionally bypassing your legal right.
 

reprotected

Distinguished
Oct 13, 2009
126
0
18,640
1
You go to PokeCommunity and see people developing their own Pokemon games and using ROM hacks that use Nintendo sprites and they aren't getting sued. As long as it isn't pay, I doubt they will sue.
 

Burodsx

Distinguished
May 31, 2009
89
0
18,580
0
What I really want is a non-kiddie version of Pokemon. It seems all the monster collecting games I have played are all cartoony. Let's have Pokemon for adults.
 

Gundam288

Distinguished
Sep 23, 2011
68
0
18,580
0
[citation][nom]IndignantSkeptic[/nom]Yah who is going to know how to build the equipment to rip the ROM themselves? The whole thing is silly, of course they are going to download it from the internet. I wish Nintendo would just stop being silly and release all their games for PC finally.[/citation]


Correct me if I am wrong, but doesn't the DMCA or some other law state that if you own the gameboy version of the game then it is legal to download the ROM and use it as you already bought the game in the 1st place?

or is the MPAA/RIAA/Etc trolling the legal system worse than I feared they already have?


I kinda see this helping Nintendo if anything. It will give them data on if people would even be willing to play a Pokemon MMO on the PC if they ever deside to make one in the future.


As for me, I lost intrest after they added more than 151 pokemon. After seeing the site and watching the trailer (in which some guy had a Whale for a pokemon following him on land o_O) I don't have any intrest in this because they have and I quote "Staff approved player contributions may be added to the game."

I'm more of a blue/red/yellow/green pokemon person. =3
 

belardo

Distinguished
Nov 23, 2008
1,143
0
19,230
0
[citation][nom]Burodsx[/nom]What I really want is a non-kiddie version of Pokemon. It seems all the monster collecting games I have played are all cartoony. Let's have Pokemon for adults.[/citation] Lets not. Wait.. you mean like some sort of furry?
 
G

Guest

Guest
belardo said:
Burodsx said:
What I really want is a non-kiddie version of Pokemon. It seems all the monster collecting games I have played are all cartoony. Let's have Pokemon for adults.
Lets not. Wait.. you mean like some sort of furry?
I think what Burodsx means is he wants a monster-collecting game with a more mature theme. The monsters one would collect, take care of, and fight with don't need to be cutesy. Not that I object to cutesy. But some more mature monsters that look intimidating, demonic, or grotesque would be greatly appreciated in a monster-collecting game. What he may have also meant was a game like Pokemon could also do with more game mechanics to make it more interesting. None of this "Four Moves per Monster" nonsense that Pokemon does. We've grown up! We want more meat in this kind of game.

(Apologies if the quote tags didn't work)
 

kinggraves

Distinguished
May 14, 2010
445
0
18,940
1
[citation][nom]IndignantSkeptic[/nom]Yah who is going to know how to build the equipment to rip the ROM themselves? The whole thing is silly, of course they are going to download it from the internet. I wish Nintendo would just stop being silly and release all their games for PC finally.[/citation]

Not going to happen. They aren't going to dilute their IP by putting it out on PC when they sell the hardware to play the software. One of Nintendo's few advantages these days is their 1st party content, and it is still working for them.

[citation][nom]ZerothDenominator[/nom]The thing is...Nintendo still believes ROMs are illegal regardless of whether or not you own the original copies.You can read all about Nintendo's stance on the ROM/Emulator scene.http://www.nintendo.com/corp/legal.jsp#download_rom[/citation]

I'm willing to bet Nintendo's lawyers have studied the ins and outs of copyright laws better than anyone discussing it here. Are there any actual cases where copying of video game content was upheld in such a manner or any actual nonpiracy sites that know something about law claiming that it is fully legal to copy over the software, or is it just the case of people going "I heard the DMCA says we can copy our games as long as we own them."? Keep in mind also that the rom in this instance is not being used for testing or archival purposes, which is where exceptions may occur. Let's even say it is legal, is the developer making no profit off of this project willing to fight over his right to modify the software in court for several years? I am not commenting at all here on what's morally correct or what "should" be the law, just what the situation really is at this current date.

But why would Nintendo take issue with this? Again, copyright dilution. They may want to release a pokemon MMO in the future, maybe they even already have one ready in case the IP starts to show signs of unpopularity. They do not want any unofficial MMOs floating around to confuse consumers. The "Poké" additive is also something they highly protect for their merchandise. I can already guarantee you this will be served a cease and desist. Nintendo isn't actually too bad about chasing down fan mods, but they do tend to shut down popular ones. Use this while it lasts.
 

zanny

Distinguished
Jul 18, 2008
4
0
18,510
0
I've just gotten my 4th badge in this, which is exactly what every other pokemon game ever should have been - the ability to friend and communicate in game with anyone else you know playing.

It has a lot of bugs though, a significant number of abilities are not implemented, pokemon abilities are not implemented, and this is just my opinion now, but FireRed feels so outdated considering many gameplay improvements made since then (damage type bound on abilities, not types, many new abilities from leveling up in newer generations). For example, Gengar is utter crap in gen 3 because ghost was a physical damage type.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
S Streaming Video & TVs 1
A Streaming Video & TVs 1
T Streaming Video & TVs 3
T Streaming Video & TVs 1
J Streaming Video & TVs 2
rutherfordsc Streaming Video & TVs 2
exfileme Streaming Video & TVs 7
exfileme Streaming Video & TVs 11
exfileme Streaming Video & TVs 9
exfileme Streaming Video & TVs 13
exfileme Streaming Video & TVs 12
exfileme Streaming Video & TVs 32
G Streaming Video & TVs 23
exfileme Streaming Video & TVs 13
exfileme Streaming Video & TVs 38
exfileme Streaming Video & TVs 8
exfileme Streaming Video & TVs 32
exfileme Streaming Video & TVs 57
G Streaming Video & TVs 14
exfileme Streaming Video & TVs 7

ASK THE COMMUNITY