Compare between lenovo y520 and hp omen 17

[doaakhalid]

Help me choose between these two laptops please
lenovo y520 and hp omen 17 knowing that i'm an architect and i use programs like 3D max , rhino , grasshopper ,revit ,maya .
So i need a laptop with perfect qualities regardless the price
I have these two to choose from

lenovo y520-15ikbn

Windows 10
Processor : core i7 - 7700 HQ
RAM : 16 GB DDR4
Hard : 128 SSD + 1 TB HDD
Display : 15.6" FHD IPS LED with card 4 GB nividia geforce GTX 1050

HP Omen 17-w200nk

Windows 10
Processor : core i7-7700 HQ
RAM : 16 GB DDR4
Hard : 128 SSD + 1 TB HDD
Display : 17.3" FHD IPS UWVA anti-glare WLED backlit (1920*1080)
With card 6GB nividia geforce GTX 1050

 

[Lutfij]

1| Might I ask where you're located?
2| If budget is not a concern here then they are both the same however you should know that there never was a 6GB version of the GTX 1050(even if it were the GTX 1050Ti model). The GTX 10600 comes in at 6GB mind you.
3| This link confirms that the HP Omen unit is equipped with the GTX 1060.

I'd get the HP Omen but you should also know that I'm architect as well and the GPU you're dealing with is meant for gaming grade duties. Asking it to computational work like that seen on AutoCAD isn't the right thing. In fact you should be looking at a laptop equipped with a Quadro or Firepro GPU which are better suited to the apps you've listed. Essentially speaking a workstation grade laptop.

If you want to game on the laptop then a workstation grade laptop isn't the right unit for the task.

 

[doaakhalid]

1) i'm from egypt
2) the budget is not a concern because i'm very desprate and i owned a toshiba laptop for years and it doesn't work anymore so i have to get another laptop ASAP to grt my work done and when i asked these were the top 2 recommendations for a good quality laptop but the difference in price is 13,000 egyptian pounds and the only difference is the screen size and graphics card so before i purschase any of them i asked which one is preferable and does it worth the differnece to get the omen ?
3) about the gaming laptop i know it's for gaming but these were the very highly recommended laptops for me i'm not intersted in gaming but when i asked the answer was that i need a laptop with qualities of a gaming laptop so i searched in that categoery

If u have any reccomendations for a good quality laptop that would be highly appreciated

 

[doaakhalid]

MERGED QUESTION
Question from doaakhalid : "Lenovo y520 vs Hp omen 17-w200nk"

If i have to choose between these two laptops which one is better ?

Lenovo y520-15ikbn

Windows: 10
Processor : core i7-7700 HQ
RAM : 16 GB DDR4
Hard : 128 SSD + 1 TB HDD
Screen display : 15.6" FHD IPS LED
Graphics card : 4 GB nividia geforce GTX 1050

Price: about 1280 $

Hp omen 17-w200nk

Windows : 10
Processor : core i7-7700 HQ
RAM: 16 GB DDR4
Hard : 128 GB SSD + 1 TB HDD
Screen display : 17.3" FHD IPS UVWA antiglare WLED Backlit (1920*1080)
Graphics card: 6 GB nividia geforce GTX 1060

Price : about 1950 $

 

[doaakhalid]

MERGED QUESTION
Question from doaakhalid : "Lenovo y520-15ikbn Vs HP Omen 17-W200nx ..PLZ HELP!!!"

If i have to choose between these two laptops with the following specs which one is better ?

Lenovo y520-15ikbn

Windows : 10
Processor : core i7-7700 HQ
RAM : 16 GB DDR4
Hard : 128 GB SSD + 1 TB HDD
Screen display : 15.6" FHD IPS LED
Graphics : 4 GB Nividia Geforce GTX 1050
Price : about 1280 $


HP Omen 17-w200nx

Windows : 10
Processor : core i7-7700 HQ
RAM : 16 GB DDR4
Hard : 128 GB SSD + 1 TB HDD
Screen display : 17.3" FHD IPS UVWA anti-glare WLED-backlit (1920*1080)
Graphics : 6 GB Nividia Geforce GTX 1060
Price : about 1950 $

They are almost the same but different in screen size and graphics card

Which is better and worth its price ?! Plz help