FBI Takes Down 3 Sites Hosting Pirated Android Apps

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the Tom's Guide community: where nearly two million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Status
Not open for further replies.

pharoahhalfdead

Distinguished
Nov 30, 2010
36
0
18,580
It's a good thing our government spends more time and money focusing on pirates instead of focusing on something that could actually be beneficial to society. I would much rather hear articles about the governments resources being spent on something like To Catch A Predator. Piracy is wrong, but our leaders have the wrong priorities. Years ago I read an article about a teenager who was arrested for making counterfeit money, and they were going to hit him with something like 8 charges, and give him 16 years in jail, yet these monster/predators go after our kids, and they get minimal time. I'm very confused about what people consider important issues.
 

army_ant7

Distinguished
May 31, 2009
26
0
18,580
"The FBI is wasting time and resources with this issue."
Well, it's not like they're totally focused on this. I mean in the real world, just because there are murder cases (grave issue) which are being addressed, but should you let things like shoplifting (milder issue) go by just because?

"Only the rich are at a loss due to pirating."
Not necessarily. There are a lot of start-up software companies, not everyone's in Microsoft, etc. Also retailers have to make a profit from the products they've purchased to sell. Not all retailers/software stores are big companies I bet. Also, it takes some skill and ingenuity which is mentioned in the article, aside from the actual labor and investment. Now, there's a reason why we pay doctor's a lot of money, though some of you may not see it as just. Could you imagine spending about 10 years of your life in Medical school? How about it's costs and risks involved? I'm not saying that it's this hard to land a career in the software development industry, but it's the same concept, the same concept that applies to all jobs to varying degrees.
Now car companies, a lot of them are rich, why not start stealing their cars? Probably because you can't get away with it so easily. This is the kind of mentality people have that plays a big part IMO in making the world as sucky as it is now.
If you're feeling like a "badass" for doing this, then think again. The way I see it, you're just being the latter half of that word.

"Piracy is harmless/a victimless crime."
Honestly, you don't take anything feasible from the developers/publishers in the most literal sense, but you do remove that sales potential they had. I mean, why would you buy something you already have/stolen? There are some people who say they would and they might, to support the developers, but how early do they plan on doing this? They'd probably want to earn up for other things first before thinking of buying the software they've pirated. In business, and in real life really, there's a difference between having money/getting payed now and later.

"Some good can come out of pirating."
I do agree with this. You can become part of a game's, movie's, etc. fan base. You can spread the word, as to advertise a software, etc. But that still doesn't necessarily justify pirating. If you say you really can't afford the software, well, you probably were able to afford a lot of stuff, maybe even the computer you're using the software on for a start? Just like anything else, software should be honestly and justfully acquired.
As an extreme form of analogy, if you kill someone, that is bad, I bet any decent person would agree. But what if the person you happened to kill was a serial killer or something planning to take many lives? You've then just saved many lives, which is something good that came out of this "bad" act. But that doesn't mean you should go around killing random people because of this possible good outcome.

"Some software are just too expensive. For example, a lot of Adobe software."
Well, like someone mentioned, these expensive software are aimed towards businesses and thus carry a "business price." And I know a lot of people could derive great use from these great software, but hey, just because I want (to own) a bulldozer or a tank doesn't mean I should steal them, no matter how much they cost. Haha! I'm being kiddy here but there's still that point. If I wanted an expensive car, I shouldn't just go about and steal it. Some people want to have so many "wants"/luxuries when some people can't even afford food or medicine in order to survive. If those people steal, that would be a Hell of a lot more understandable (though I'm not saying it's good) than pirating software. I mean, our ancestors didn't really find what they didn't have back then (software or even computers) vital to survival or just plain "living." And hey, there are free software, though they could be (though not necesserily are) not as good as their paid counterparts, they are free!


I used to be a rampant pirate (Yes, with an eyepatch and pegleg. Haha!). But if you think about this issue well enough, you might come to understanding what's so wrong about it. Before, I was able to get good games free by Torrent'ing, but now, I have to earn up for them, but I know this is the right honest way to do things, and people should think more like that. I hope people agree with that. I realized as well that they're more gratifying to play when you have to wait and work for them, just like anything else I guess. Hehehe...

I remember finding this article before. It proved to be reasonable. If you're a pirate, but a still consider yourself to be decent, read this: http://www.tweakguides.com/Piracy_1.html One of the things I remember it saying was that if you're a pirate (and don't plan on stopping), then stop justifying it and just admit that you're doing wrong.
I hope I'm able to reach out to some people here.
 

velias

Honorable
Aug 23, 2012
2
0
10,510
Its always nice to see the 13 year old children out in force to tell the FBI to screw themselves. Grow up idiots. It really is sad that people think free software should be an entitlement....screw the people writing the software eh?
 

velias

Honorable
Aug 23, 2012
2
0
10,510
Its always nice to see the 13 year old children out in force to tell the FBI to screw themselves. Grow up idiots. It really is sad that people think free software should be an entitlement....screw the people writing the software eh?
 

lamorpa

Distinguished
Apr 30, 2008
617
1
18,930
[citation][nom]jdwii[/nom]If i cant afford something i wont be able to buy it at least i can say i love it and tell other people and maybe they will be able to afford it.All this hurts is people who get paid lots of money any ways.[/citation]
Translation: i can multitask: im juvenile, naive, envious, self-centered, selfish, and inconsiderate all at the same time!
 

heizenbrg

Honorable
Aug 2, 2012
5
0
10,510
[citation][nom]jdog2pt0[/nom]When one goes down, many more pop up in its place. It's an uphill battle, and telling someone they can't do something is the absolute best way to get them to go do it. All this anti-pirate crap just encourages them. My thoughts on the matter? Just let it be.[/citation]
Yup, that's why I always tell people not to pop zits, they always come back, with some ugly scarring too. You just need patience and make them all go away.
 

jarred125

Honorable
Aug 9, 2012
7
0
10,510
It just makes me laugh hearing people say they can't afford a couple dollar app. Give me a break, you have zero excuses because the device in your hand cost you quite a bit more than the app you're pirating did. Also, you spent $30 a month on a data plan, you can afford it, don't even try to explain that you cant, it just makes you sound pathetic.
 

nebun

Distinguished
Oct 20, 2008
1,160
0
19,240
[citation][nom]altriss[/nom]like taking down mega upload and aggressing Dotcom? Yes they have plenty of work to do... (sarcasm)It's kinda scary to see the last FBI news we heard are more or less always about protecting companies, as a non us citizen I have a question, is it the original goal of FBI? Or did that goal changed? Or maybe FBI does a lot of other things we don't hear about, but if so why is there no communication about those actions? just wondering...[/citation]
good point....i guess they do regulate a lot more than we know...just look how the US military is trying to regulate every country...it is very sad....sometimes i am ashamed to say that i am an American...we have killed so many innocent people
 

heizenbrg

Honorable
Aug 2, 2012
5
0
10,510
[citation][nom]jarred125[/nom]It just makes me laugh hearing people say they can't afford a couple dollar app. Give me a break, you have zero excuses because the device in your hand cost you quite a bit more than the app you're pirating did. Also, you spent $30 a month on a data plan, you can afford it, don't even try to explain that you cant, it just makes you sound pathetic.[/citation]
I have to spend more than 150 a month on a family plan just to get good internet access, and that's more than I spend on gas (I'm a student and don't go around much during weekdays).
Back when I lived in Europe the phone bill was more than 4 times less, everything is more expensive in capitalistic america, you have to almost pay for a glass of water on an american airline while on the others it's just basic accomodation.

 

dauntekong

Distinguished
May 26, 2011
22
0
18,560
AND THE WORLD IS SAFE AGAIN! From what... pirating? They are the Robinhood for some people...

The FBI should really focus on real crimes and not virtual crimes.
 

heizenbrg

Honorable
Aug 2, 2012
5
0
10,510
[citation][nom]dauntekong[/nom]AND THE WORLD IS SAFE AGAIN! From what... pirating? They are the Robinhood for some people...The FBI should really focus on real crimes and not virtual crimes.[/citation]
yea, instead of closing sites and medical marijuana shops they should focus on real issues and catch the bad guys.
 

chino1985

Honorable
Aug 27, 2012
3
0
10,510
FBI downloaded android apps???? How can they bitch about it when the broke the law too? They illegally downloaded apps knowing that they where bootlegging them too. Hypocritical pieces of shit, they should get the same treatment as everyone else for knowingly downloading illegal apps, just because they use it against someone in court does not make it right, shouldn't someone use there own guns against them. What ever happened to the FBI catching the bad guys? I guess this is what you get when you have nothing to do except for standing around jerking off to child porn. It's human free right and will to take what ever they want and you better believe me I exercise that right often. So if the can convict someone for stealing, then I can convict one of them for stealing my information. Numerous times I have traced someone tracking my computer from the FBI office in Chicago. I bet they think i'm a terrorist. Well peoples the only actual terrorists is our government, they imitated 2004 Madrid train bombing. We call it 911. People need to pull there head out of there ass, when it boils down to it, it's all about money .
 
Status
Not open for further replies.