Google Ordered to Kill Autocomplete Results for One Man

Status
Not open for further replies.

amigafan

Distinguished
Mar 19, 2011
47
0
18,590
3
Fair enough. But this should not be an exception. Google should react (positively) to all reasonable requests concerning breach of personal privacy. What bothers me is that this man had to get a lawyer and sue to get it sorted out.
 

gilgamex101

Distinguished
Oct 17, 2011
3
0
18,510
0
Small things like helping this guy out with an obvious google indexing mistake shouldn't be a chore. This guy probably ended up losing money too in lawyer fees and needless headaches from court dates that are just completely uneccessary when I'm sure it would take a google programmer less than an hour to deal with this. Not to mention a 0% impact on their revenue, which is the hissy fit starter of the last 100 years.

Rediculous.
 

in_the_loop

Distinguished
Dec 15, 2007
48
0
18,580
0
[citation][nom]amigafan[/nom]Fair enough. But this should not be an exception. Google should react (positively) to all reasonable requests concerning breach of personal privacy. What bothers me is that this man had to get a lawyer and sue to get it sorted out.[/citation]

Problem is that if this become common it would be impossible for google to handle all requests.
I am seing a future where google is handling all sorts of requests for special treatment when it comes to search results.
It would make it impossible for google to function as it is.
Almost everything can be seen as a breach of personal privacy.
I think there should be another way for people to judge information about a person on the web, like with WOT (Web of Trust).
Google can not in any sense or way be answering all request like this if it goes on.
The only other way out is to filter out google completely. Or just shut it down. And that is something a lot of companies like Apple, Facebook really would cheer!
And these two companies are the really bad guys when it comes to fair play(Apple) and personal integrity(Facebook).
Not to mention the MPAA and the likes.
And I wonder why Microsoft never is mentioned in cases like this. They have a small share of the search market with Bing. But it is the default search engine in a lot of scenarios (Internet explorer default and is some smartphones).
 

fixxxer113

Distinguished
Aug 26, 2011
56
0
18,590
3
That is beyond stupid.... His name?? really?? So if my name was Charles Manson, and I kept getting results about murders on Google, should I be offended?? Should I get my name "cleaned up" on Google and mess up legitimate searches other people make for research?? Unless he is the only person in the world with that name, there is no reason to alter search results...
 

alidan

Distinguished
Aug 5, 2009
1,681
0
19,730
0
[citation][nom]fixxxer113[/nom]That is beyond stupid.... His name?? really?? So if my name was Charles Manson, and I kept getting results about murders on Google, should I be offended?? Should I get my name "cleaned up" on Google and mess up legitimate searches other people make for research?? Unless he is the only person in the world with that name, there is no reason to alter search results...[/citation]

you dont understand how japan works. ill relate this to another practice they have.

we have all seen their trains right, how crowed they get.
some people take advantage of that and grope women
the problem is so bad that they have women only carriages
well now, if a woman says you did it, even without proof, you are taken into custody and berated till you confess.
now this seams like a minor crime, toy could just have brushed them by accident, but you are guilty, your name gets put in papers and so forth.

99% of the time, you lose your job and will never get a job at a company (white collar is the japanese holly grail) again, and the only work you can do is part time like work, or working manual labor (severely looked down on). and a good portion of people who get accused kill themselves because it would honestly be easier (the way their society works and the general mindset of never stick out, or be noticeable, they may not be wrong)

this guy was most likely accused of gropeing on the train, something which is a false accusation most of the time, and got screwed because of it.
 

eiskrystal

Distinguished
May 11, 2007
89
0
18,580
0
Japanese businesses need to get their act together if they are firing employees for crimes not committed based on a dodgy websearch. Otherwise they will simply be sued into administration. Which is what this guy should have done as well.
 

Lord Captivus

Distinguished
Sep 13, 2011
27
0
18,580
0
"Though the man insists he knows nothing about these crimes, his lawyer says it's likely that Google linked his name to these terms because of an inaccurate story that spread across various sites and was subsequently indexed by Google. "
Mmm....inaccurate?...mmm....that sounds like theres a chance this guy actually did something wrong...Mmmm....
What if it is true? Can i sue Google when my co-worker is murdered by this guy, because Google deleted the info??
Mmm....this could be a problem...maybe not for this guy...but for others...
 

amigafan

Distinguished
Mar 19, 2011
47
0
18,590
3
[citation][nom]in_the_loop[/nom]Problem is that if this become common it would be impossible for google to handle all requests.[/citation]
This also crossed my mind -- but it could be fully automated. For example whoever has a Google account in their name (gmail for example) Google could provide those users a limited possibility (options) to manage search results (and autocomplete if anything gets associated) which are directly concerning them (such as first and last name, address etc.).
 

stoogie

Distinguished
Jun 11, 2010
65
0
18,580
0
Google should pay that man damages for the amount of money he couldve earned in that job that he lost because of google and also for the lawyer fees.
 

JPForums

Distinguished
Oct 9, 2007
19
0
18,560
0
Google should pay that man damages for the amount of money he couldve earned in that job that he lost because of google and also for the lawyer fees.
Google doesn't write the story, it just finds the story. Just because Google doesn't auto-complete the search for you doesn't mean the story isn't out there.

The Japanese man says these autocomplete suggestions cost him his job several years ago ...
No proof. This is an opinion. Further, I don't think anyone responsible for hiring would start to type his name in a search bar and make a decision based on suggestions that popped up. They would at least take a look at the related link.

... and other companies that have rescinded job offers have said that the search results were a factor.
The search results, not the auto-complete suggestions, must have been sufficiently compelling. Again, removing auto-complete doesn't change the search or the story. If he wants to fix the problem, he needs to press charges against the author that libeled him.
 

gwwerner

Distinguished
Nov 3, 2009
19
0
18,560
0
So Google will stop autocomplete from suggesting anything about the crimes, but a search for his name should still bring up links to the news stories about the crimes. Has he really accomplished anything? Will the next lawsuit of this type require that Google not return results linking to the objectionable pages?
 

mkyan978

Distinguished
Jan 6, 2010
3
0
18,510
0
The article doesn't say that Google has decided to comply. The more I think about it, the more I feel like Google shouldn't comply with this absurd order.
 

Anomalyx

Distinguished
Apr 2, 2010
195
0
18,630
0
Tom's failed to mention one of the most interesting points of this story... Google refused to comply with the order, since its US servers are not under Japanese jurisdiction.
 

f-14

Distinguished
Apr 2, 2010
774
0
18,940
4
[citation][nom]eiskrystal[/nom]Japanese businesses need to get their act together if they are firing employees for crimes not committed based on a dodgy websearch. Otherwise they will simply be sued into administration. Which is what this guy should have done as well.[/citation]
it is japan, the emporer did not grant them that kind of power or tool and we the usa were too chicken to beat it into them despite resorting to atomic bombs.
stop assuming the rest of the world is JUST LIKE THE STATES, they aren't that's why we have so damn many conflicts and problems with them.
we have to invade them and take over and install puppets that our businessmen and leaders can control for that to happen.
 
G

Guest

Guest
Sometimes it's really useful, like when looking up republican presidential candidates, such as Santorum.
 

zaznet

Distinguished
May 10, 2010
262
0
18,930
0
[citation][nom]gwwerner[/nom]So Google will stop autocomplete from suggesting anything about the crimes, but a search for his name should still bring up links to the news stories about the crimes. Has he really accomplished anything? Will the next lawsuit of this type require that Google not return results linking to the objectionable pages?[/citation]

You need to realize what auto-complete does. It does NOT provide the search result. It provides key words as suggestions after other words that have been indexed together. If you type your first name and wait, you should see some suggestions. Type one of those OR your own last name and you may see additional suggestions. If one of those suggestions is murderer then anyone doing a search on your name may get a surprise.

Subsequently they may search for your First and Last name with "Murderer" in the search where they may have only previously searched by just the first and last name without the suggestion being provided.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
D Streaming Video & TVs 0
E Streaming Video & TVs 1
P Streaming Video & TVs 4
Adom Streaming Video & TVs 2
R Streaming Video & TVs 0
R Streaming Video & TVs 0
R Streaming Video & TVs 0
B Streaming Video & TVs 4
L Streaming Video & TVs 2
N Streaming Video & TVs 2
T Streaming Video & TVs 3
A Streaming Video & TVs 2
A Streaming Video & TVs 1
S Streaming Video & TVs 0
S Streaming Video & TVs 0
S Streaming Video & TVs 3
O Streaming Video & TVs 1
A Streaming Video & TVs 1
D Streaming Video & TVs 2
Z Streaming Video & TVs 10

ASK THE COMMUNITY