Is Dell's XPS M1710 The Fastest Graphics Notebook Computer Ever?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the Tom's Guide community: where nearly two million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Marauder

Distinguished
Dec 15, 2005
4
0
18,510
I currently own a Inspirion 9300 from Dell with 1.89GHz Pent M, 6800 GT 256, 1gig 433MHz ram. I dont know if they offer this kind of setup on Dell laptops anymore with out going with the XPS, but I was able to get a faster CPU and more RAM/HDD space by choosing the Inspirion series and just upgrading the parts.

Yeah sure I dont have the cool lights or custom case like the XPS, but who really needs that other than for showing off.

I cant really get more than 1.5 hours of battery life out of mine and if I remember correctly I have the larger 12cell battery. Battery life is hardly extended even with no USB connections and screen brightness turned to low, etc.

I love my laptop. Although I would love the new XPS even more! But really, who wants to pay $4300 on a new laptop that has current top end technology today, but tomorrow is eating the dust of newer and faster systems/games? I just now paid off mine and it is already almost obsolete and i paid less than half as much...
 

mat347

Distinguished
Mar 15, 2006
6
0
18,510
Marauder, I wouldn't say that setup is almost obsolete. Many laptops are upgradeable with more RAM, faster CPUs, bigger/faster hard drives. The only exception being GPUs(at least from OEM) due to the proprietary sockets/cooling solutions. If you plan on any upgrades for games, a newer GPU would be your best bet, the 1.89/1gig is not the limiting factors, but the GPU is. You may also try overclocking that card, it will have to be done with a BIOS flash as Dell locks everything from overclocking :evil:
 

Marauder

Distinguished
Dec 15, 2005
4
0
18,510
Do you know of any place where I could get an upgraded GPU? I looked on PriceWatch.com and could not find anything.

The only things that I think needs to be upgraded would be the GPU and HDD. And yeah when i was refering to my laptop being behind the times I mostly meant gaming since thats the main usage and seemingly the only bump in the road for performance when it comes to the newest games.

Also do you know of any good reference material i can read up on for flashing the bios for overclocking and getting information on if its possible to replace the GPU in my model?
 

spectrablue

Distinguished
Apr 20, 2006
2
0
18,510
Please remove the 6800 ultra card on the xps gen 2 and replace it with the 7900 nvidia card from the new laptop and then run the tests again on the gen 2. I would like to see 1) if the new card works on the xps gen 2 as an upgrade and 2) how the performance compares with the gen 2 and the new dual core laptop with the same video card. If anyone has the skills and resources to help the Dell xps gen 2 users through this it must be the TG folks. One of the touted benefits of the video card slot in the xps laptop line was that it could be upgraded. Please prove to us that this is the case and rerun the tests. I realize that this is going to be a complete pain in the ... to do but please please please consider swapping the video cards and run some more tests. THANKS.
 

mat347

Distinguished
Mar 15, 2006
6
0
18,510
The upgrade will quite probably need to come from Dell, I don't think the XPS follows the few laptop standards there are.
I can't quite remember the program names that I used...I'll update when I get home...but there are two...one to read the default BIOS and edit it..the other to flash using a bootable disk. It says that you shouldn't use the CDROM to flash, but about 6 times with 0 problems.

The only way I upgraded was that my bud ordered a Gen2 that DIDN'T want the 7800 upgrade, I paid the difference and we swapped cards. I think Dell wants to do the upgrade themselves...warranty issue maybe?? It's not hard, just allot of small screws.

It would be cool to get some gaming @ the native 1920x1200 res, the 7800GTX isn't quite up to it, I don't think the 7900 will be either, not with everything turned on anyway. Oblivion plays OK @ the 1280 widescreen res with everything but grass shadows(tends to slow things down allot).



UPDATE: OK the programs I used are Bit Torrent V2.7 to edit the BIOS, and NVFlash to write it to the cards BIOS. I used ATITool to verify max tems and to search for any artifacts the overclocking may cause.
 

warchief_ryan

Distinguished
Apr 21, 2006
3
0
18,510
8O First off didn’t you see the SLI Laptop from Rocket Direct and Sager? It is the fastest gaming laptop hands down and it doesn’t cost 4500+, the sager is around 3000 I belive, phrenlee nice laptop but over priced and the SLI laptop would leave it in the dust with its DUAL 7800GTX’s. and maybe its me but why give a laptop such a high rez? They are already slower then desktops and most people I know with gaming desktops never run or can’t do 1920x1200.

The SLI Laptop is the King of gaming lappys and that’s what the Dell needs to beat. For Fastest Graphics Notebook Computer Ever Title…

Compare the Dell vs the Sagers SLI…

Chief.
 

sarkoa

Distinguished
Apr 21, 2006
1
0
18,510
I purchased a Dell 1705 and would like to see how it compares. I'm also wondering if the GPU can be upgraded. My 1705 came with the Go 7800. I'd like to see if there's that much difference in the machines. The 1705 has been able to handle Battlefield 2 without a problem. I thought with the 7800 the battery life would be poor but It's held up quite well.
 

niev

Distinguished
Apr 22, 2006
1
0
18,510
I would like to see how this compares to the 19' dual graphics notebooks with AMD Turion and Nvidia SLI announced by Alienware, vodooPC, evesham, etc...
 

FatFunkey

Distinguished
Apr 11, 2006
4
0
18,510
SWEET A LABTOP THAT HAS A 20MIN BAT LIFE :D

OH AND I CAN GO SLI??? AND GET 10MIN??? NO WAI!!!!


the point of a labtop is to be portible.....sheesh
 

warchief_ryan

Distinguished
Apr 21, 2006
3
0
18,510
The SlI laptop is a DESKTOP REPLACEMENT, its still vary portable as in you can pick it up to take it somewhere but it’s made for GAMING.

Most gaming laptops don’t ever get unplugged except to take them to a lan party, then there right back plugged in. If you want good battery life get some 15in pos that you can only type on.

Chief.
 

FatFunkey

Distinguished
Apr 11, 2006
4
0
18,510
k.orrr what i was looking at an abs G4 Revolution
2.0ghz p4
6600Gt 256
1 gig DDR2 Ram

but sure if i can only type on it

i find it to be a waste to buy a desktop replacement labtop, you cant o/cem cuz they heat up and it defeats the purpose of a labtop..por
 

phrenlee

Distinguished
Apr 18, 2006
9
0
18,510
Yeah, latop is pricey...

I looked at the sli performance numbers and they are about 60% faster than the single solution.

I paid extra for the dual fx60 and the 2x100(7200) raid 0 config. They also had the sli 7800 config available. I preferred the dual-core with higher screen res due to the fact that I do alot of development. I use vmware extensively with sometimes 4 VMs running. The higher resolution is very helpful in those situations.

I would agree that the dual sli config with lower screen res would be a better gaming machine.

btw: Anyone know what happened to xvxonline.com? They have been unvailable for a week now.
 

happy_acid_face

Distinguished
May 9, 2006
1
0
18,510
Warchief Ryan... I think you may need to read into this laptop a little more, check out the benchmark results in this review

http://www.notebookreview.com/default.asp?newsID=2887&review=Dell+XPS+M1710

but if your not bothered reading that, here's an extract from one of the tests...

"Half-Life 2: Lost Coast HDR Demo

Settings: 1920x1200 resolution, maximum settings, Full HDR (High Dynamic Range)
8X AF: 55FPS

Half-Life 2: Lost Coast is probably one of the most demanding games (it is actually a demo for HDR) to run at full resolution due to the High Dynamic Range. It is incredibly stressful on the GPU, and equally so on the processor. The XPS M1710 doesn't even break a sweat playing the demo -- the lowest FPS observed was 39, during the very beginning scene. Playing at such an extreme resolution is, for lack of better words, awe-inspiring."

The laptop seems to be able to handle 1920x1200 with ease. Its quite amazing.

FatFunky... try reading the review too. The laptop has a very respectable battery life for a machine of such power.

"With the screen brightness at 6/7 (near maximum, keep in mind), wireless at full power, and while surfing the Internet, I clocked the battery power to be two hours and five minutes. That's not bad at all. You could certainly add more time if you turned down the brightness."

Also, the arcitechure of the motherboard in this laptop was totally redesigned to acount for its heat. The two main generators of heat in a laptop are the CPU and the graphics card. They are now placed at opposite sides of the board displacing the heat. From all the reviews i've read on sites it seems one of its comendable features is its LOW heat.

Being a DTR, its bound to be at the heavier end of the market. but weighing in at 8lbs (10 including the power cable) its a laptop i could easily carry around. When i was younger and in school my school bag and books weighed around twice that. That much power at 8lbs is hardly a complaint.

Lastly, Marketed as a gaming laptop the XPS does not get the credit for its other great abilities. As someone who uses 3D Studio max and Cinema 4D alot such a power graphics card that is also portable is of great use to me.
 

e23

Distinguished
May 12, 2006
1
0
18,510
What has your post got to do with supreme notebooks ?
Did you feel you just had to tell people about your DESK TOP pc that has not actually arrived yet ?


wasteful post..
 

phrenlee

Distinguished
Apr 18, 2006
9
0
18,510
Reply to e23.

Well .. I am just curious about how the dell stacks up against the other laptops on the market. The laptop I got is based upon the CLEVO D900K. Alot of companies sell this exact same laptop under their re-branded name.

I was just hoping my post would encourage comparisions. Some people are moving away from desktop gaming rigs to laptop gaming systems. Anything that helps all of us make a better buying decision, especially when spending close to 5K, is very helpful. I like to get the most for my money, as much as possible.

My laptop did finally arrive. It is very, very, very fast. I am addicted to RAID 0 on a laptop now. I am very impressed by the system. I, as of yet, have not played any games on it.

Unfortunately, the company that I bought the system from, has disappeared. I am at a loss and highly disappointed about that. I really hope they overcome the challenges they face and reappear.

I would recommend this particular CLEVO based system to anyone considering buying an extremely fast laptop. Due to the heat generated by it, I do not feel that it is usable laptop without an external mouse. The top of the laptop can get very hot. It is best mounted on a laptop stand, preferable one with some usb ports on it. With a good external mouse and keyboard, it makes for an excellent portable DESKTOP.

I would only buy this if you had the extra cash to spend, otherwise save your money for retirement.

It is my opinion, after having used the CLEVO, that the DELL is probably a better choice if you still want to use your DTR as a laptop (without external keyboard and mouse). Dell is also an established company with better support. Dell's are also easier to sell on ebay. That is important when you want to get rid of your machine in one year to get the LATEST and GREATEST!

e23: You have a right to your opinion, but, posting a short message that does not really contribute to the content of the thread, can be construed as wasteful. I am very sure that you are capable of creating constructive content, and I look forward to reading those kind of posts from you! BTW: It is not a desktop PC. It feels like one, but the lcd is connected to the the keyboard, touchpad, and the rest of the system components. Just like other laptops! <grin>

If anyone has insight into what happened to xvxonline.com, it would be highly appreciated.
 

phrenlee

Distinguished
Apr 18, 2006
9
0
18,510
For everyone who is getting a laptop that support 4Gb of RAM.

Apparently XP Pro supports 4Gb of ram. Using the /3GB switch in the boot.ini file, you can force the OS to use 1GB for OS operations and 3GB for apps. This is contradictory to all of the other posts I have read. I hope someone finds this useful.

[boot loader]
timeout=30
default=multi(0)disk(0)rdisk(0)partition(2)WINNT
[operating systems]
multi(0)disk(0)rdisk(0)partition(2)WINNT="????" /3GB

Follow the link for details from Microsoft.
Memory support on Windows.
 

warchief_ryan

Distinguished
Apr 21, 2006
3
0
18,510
Im not saying the Dell is slow but the SLI Lappy is faster at gaming, and the Dell is definitely not fast with the new Alienware SLI Laptop that has Dual 7900GTX’s!!!!