You Can Now Go to Jail for Not Giving Your iPhone Passcode

Status
Not open for further replies.

rekabis

Distinguished
Apr 26, 2008
4
0
18,510
0
The line between what a judge can force you to divulge and what they cannot boils down to between what you have and what you know, respectively. A key, which is something you have, can be forced from your possession. As such, a judge can force you to provide a fingerprint in order to unlock your phone. However, a safe combination is something you know, and therefore immune from being compelled. As such, a phone passphrase cannot be compelled because it is something you know, not possess.

The distinction is that an object in your possession can be retrieved whether or not you remember that you have it or even know that you have it. It does not rely on your state of mind to be retrieved, and can be retrieved independently of your state of mind. Something that you know requires you to be in a fit state of mind in order for it to be retrieved; if there was no protection against an unfit state of mind, you could easily be jailed indefinitely for something you truly forgot about or did not even know about -- a horrifying travesty of justice that the abusive elements in our justice system could - and would - eagerly abuse.

Any judge who violates the balance of these two simple rules has no business being a judge. Full stop, no exceptions. Violation of this balance indicates gross incompetence and fundamental unfitness to be a judge.

As the old saying goes, better a guilty man walk free than an innocent man be incarcerated for even a single day.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
Jameswantanswer Android Smartphones 1
S Android Smartphones 1
E Android Smartphones 1
G Android Smartphones 1
M Android Smartphones 1
G Android Smartphones 0
N Android Smartphones 2
S Android Smartphones 1
M Android Smartphones 1
S Android Smartphones 5
G Android Smartphones 9
P Android Smartphones 1
Mark Spoonauer Android Smartphones 2
J Android Smartphones 1
M Android Smartphones 1
M Android Smartphones 1
K Android Smartphones 1
L Android Smartphones 1
B Android Smartphones 1
A Android Smartphones 1
Similar threads
Question my phone gives vcalendar permission to send email invitations without my knowledge. is that normal?
Question What does it mean on my list of downloads, it reads "using 9.49g of 9.14g" Not sure what other info to give or how to ask more precisely. Any feedback
Does not give option on Google setting for ads
OnePlus Wants To Give Us Smaller Phones At Last
i lost my phone yesterday the model is j7 pro samsung ,i had give police complaint also but im not confident on them ..pls hel
T-Mobile Giving Away Free Samsung 4K TV with Note 9, Galaxy S9
give me my 2017 to 2018 all old Facebook pictures
I accidentally deleted my dcim folder from my mobiles internal storage plz give me a solution to restore the folder cause I ha
I have a lot of pics on drive but my phone gives me an error when I want to view them. 'Error retrieving additional items'. Pl
My lg rebel 2 is out of internal storage and does not give the option to use sd card as internal storage. What do i do
Moto G4 giving low space when still has loads of space left!
Give me my deleted images
Giving Away Free Google Home Minis Is the Dumbest Idea Ever
My LG Fiesta just stopped ringing or vibrating when a call comes in it still gives me the alert when I get a message
Every time I try to log in it will only give me my son's account even though I've used my mobile number and my email
When I press power to wipe cache partition on a galaxy s7 edge should it give any feedback?
My friend will not give me her number because she does not want me to do a lyric prank on her and i told her i would not and s
My phone is requesting to give her my old gmail. account
I don't have an sd card yet its giving me an error "image download failed due to missing sd card"..
please give my Facebook photos which I unfortunately deleted from gallery

ASK THE COMMUNITY

TRENDING THREADS