I was blown away by how solid the new Macbooks feel. Everything else I see now looks and feels like a cheap plastic piece of junk born out of designed obsolescence. I have to admit the 17" MacBook is way more than I'm willing to pay. I wouldn't carry $3,000 in cash around with me, let alone flash it around. I just can't justify spending so much. I would cover mine in stickers to play down it's sexiness...part of what you are paying for. I also want 8gb of ram, and this option on the 17" MacBook Pro is just ridiculously expensive. I also like to dock my laptop and use multiple monitors when I get home...not that you couldn't do this on the 17" Macbook pro with some 3rd party magic widget, but it is less justification for a 17" monitor for me. I say, if you live on a laptop, and love all the features, live somewhere where flashing $3000 around won't get clobbered over the head, and don't want an affordable 8gb option, I say go for it!