Archived from groups: alt.video.ptv.tivo (
More info?)
On Fri, 13 May 2005 18:44:10 -0000, Mike Hunt <in2sheep@yahoo.com>
wrote:
>On 2005-05-13, Sean <none> wrote:
>> On 13 May 2005 16:03:50 GMT, here@n.now wrote:
>>
>>>HowdyDoody <howdy@doody.com> wrote:
>>>> I have DirecTivo now and will be moving shortly and want to get HD
>>>> programming. What is necessary to go from what I have now to HD
>>>> programming as far as the components I need?
>>>
>>>> .... or do I have to buy a HD DVR as well ?
>>>
>>>Yes.
>>>
>>
>> Don't waste the $1,000. It will be obsolete soon. What these Tivo
>> rumpswabs won't tell you is the new DTV sats going up will not be
>> compatible with HD Tivo's.
>
>It's not a waste - you get a HD DVR by spending the money. When will it
>be obsolete? 2009? 2015? What's your definition of obsolete? If it is
>'to stop working', it's going to be _a long_ time before it stops working
>as an MPEG2 HD DVR since MPEG2 HD is going to be around for a long time.
>
>No one disagrees about the new DTV sats going up - the new sats are MPEG4
>and all the current HD DVRs are MPEG2. This means in the future, you will
>be able to get the exact same HD feeds you are getting today, but not the
>new ones from these new sats. They have also made the claim there will be
>a trade-in program to trade-in your MPEG2 HD DVR for an MPEG4 HD DVR.
>Regardless, this doesn't make the current model obsolete.
Who made that "trade in" claim? Care to cite a reference? Besides,
according to you tivo rumpswabs the new NDS dvr is vaporware that will
never work, right?
I bet the OP will be real thrilled to shell out $1,000 and as DTV
rolls out more + more HD channels he can't record them.
Oh, yeah. That would not piss me off.
If it wasn't for me, noone in this NG would have pointed that out.
You Tivo Rumpswabs.
Sean