Macbook pro second hard drive (superdrive) is very slow

Status
Not open for further replies.

GuillaumeBertrand

Commendable
Nov 6, 2016
3
0
1,510
0
Hi everyone,

I just bought a MBP i7 with a 250go SSD and a 1To drive replacing the superdrive.

This second drive has very slow transfer rates. (It took it about 5 hours to copy 50 Gb from a firewire 800 external disk).
It take ages to show the folder contents, (as if it needed to rest sometimes).
I tried running disk utility repair function, I tried reformating it. No improvements.

I took it to the shop where I bought it, they replaced the drive and still no improvements. Do I need to update the Macbook EFI ? SMC ? Or is it totally unrelated.

My OS X version is 10.9.4.

System info :

Informations matériel :

Nom du modèle : MacBook Pro
Identifiant du modèle : MacBookPro8,2
Nom du processeur : Intel Core i7
Vitesse du processeur : 2,5 GHz
Nombre de processeurs : 1
Nombre total de cœurs : 4
Cache de niveau 2 (par cœur) : 256 Ko
Cache de niveau 3 : 8 Mo
Mémoire : 16 Go
Version de la ROM de démarrage : MBP81.0047.B27
Version SMC (système) : 1.69f4
Numéro de série (système) : C02HD0QKDV7P
UUID du matériel : A68D5BC7-BC63-5EF8-BDF6-C07C9E4448B9
Capteur de mouvement brusque :
État : Activé



System info regarding this drive :

Intel 6 Series Chipset :

Fournisseur : Intel
Produit : 6 Series Chipset
Vitesse de la liaison : 6 Gigabits
Vitesse de liaison négociée : 6 Gigabits
Interconnexion physique : SATA
Description : AHCI Version 1.30 Supported

ST1000LM024 HN-M101MBB :

Capacité : 1 To (1 000 204 886 016 octets)
Modèle : ST1000LM024 HN-M101MBB
Révision : 2BA30001
Numéro de série : S2ZWJL0G901881
NCQ (Native Command Queuing) : Oui
Profondeur de la file d’attente : 32
Support amovible : Non
Disque amovible : Non
Nom BSD : disk1
Vitesse de rotation : 5400
Type de média : Rotation
Type de carte de partition : GPT (Tableau de partition GUID)
État S.M.A.R.T. : Vérifié
Volumes :
EFI :
Capacité : 209,7 Mo (209 715 200 octets)
Nom BSD : disk1s1
Contenu : EFI
SuperDrive :
Capacité : 999,86 Go (999 860 912 128 octets)
Disponible : 943,32 Go (943 322 083 328 octets)
Inscriptible : Oui
Système de fichiers : HFS+ journalisé
Nom BSD : disk1s2
Point de montage : /Volumes/SuperDrive
Contenu : Apple_HFS
UUID du volume : 384461C6-CF9D-395A-916C-2008945D0B8D


Any clue ?
 

BadAsAl

Distinguished
Can you run a disk speed check on the second hard drive to confirm it is slower than expected? I have used BlackMagic to test Mac drives before. You should be seeing speeds in the 50 to 100 MB/s range.
 

GuillaumeBertrand

Commendable
Nov 6, 2016
3
0
1,510
0


I downloaded Blackmagic speed test.

The first time a ran it, it froze on the "read" phase, and a minute later, the disk ejected itself. With the message "The disk was not ejected properly. If possible, always eject a disk before unplugging it or turning it off.".
(Yeah I forgot to mention in my first post, it ejects like this from time to time when I copy files on it, or when I try to access it).

I tried many times, it seems to go on sleep mode and be innaccessible for a while sometimes.

When I managed to get a correct try on blackmagic test, without freezing states, it gave me about 100 mb write and about 100 mb read. I'd love it to work like this all the time, but I don't know how to reproduce the times when it works correctly and the times it just pauses and freezes.
 

GuillaumeBertrand

Commendable
Nov 6, 2016
3
0
1,510
0
No BIOS equivalent on the Mac. But that is definately a lead regarding speed negociation.
From the forum posts you submitted it seems that the problem comes from SATA III and SATA II differences.

My System Info says it's negociating 6 Gigabits but the drive is a SATA II drive, which is unable to negociate such speeds.
The solution is to have the correct speed negociation. I see three potential leads :
- I will try tomorrow to open it up and see if the drive has a jumper to limit speed negociation. That seems to solve those drops for other users.
- Another thing would be to use a SATA III drive which would negociate the right speed that the intel chipset demands.
- And finally the SATA adapter could also be an issue, using a SATA II adapter could tell the chipset to negociate 3 Gigabits that the disk can handle.

I'll come back to you if I find something that works for me.

In the meantime, thanks to all of you for your time, and if you have other clues, I'd be happy to hear it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ASK THE COMMUNITY