MSI or Asus

[Peter206]

Hi , I would like to buy gaming laptop .
I found this:
MSI GT72S 6QE-044UK
http/www.laptopsdirect.ie/msi-gt72s-6qe-044uk-skylake-i7-6820hk-32gb-1tb-512gbssd-nvidia-geforce-gt-9s7-178211-612/version.asp
Or
Asus G752VY ROG
http/www.laptopsdirect.ie/asus-gaming-core-i7-6820hk-32gb-1tb-17.3-windows-10-64-bit-laptop-g752vy-t7049t/version.asp
I prefer Asus
There is about 300€ different price. Is it for gtx980 8gb ? It is big performance difference?
Thank you.

 

[jimmyEatWord]

MSI of course is cheaper

 

[Peter206]

MSI of course is cheaper

Do you think MSI is better quality than Asus ? And has better performance ?

 

[Dulith1118]

really depends whether u want that extra vram or not...But yeah Asus one would be okay to go with..
Won't make any huge difference since both same card

 

[Martell1977]

My experiences have been that ASUS has been top notch quality while I've always had problems with MSI products.

As for specs on these laptops, the MSI is a bit confusing. The listing says 512gb SSD, yet in the "tech specs" it says 128gb SSD, so it's unclear what they are actually selling.

Both listings contradict themselves for RAM, the listing says 32gb (for both), yet again, the "tech specs" says "Maximum Internal Memory" is 8gb...

Are you sure that website is a reputable retailer?

 

[jimmyEatWord]

MSI of course is cheaper

Do you think MSI is better quality than Asus ? And has better performance ?

i've never had a gaming laptop myself , but on the desktop , the asus OC wizard is an immitation of MSI's OC genie , they came up with the idea , ASUS is dam expensive !

 

[Martell1977]

ASUS is dam expensive !

In this case...the ASUS is the cheaper of the 2.

 

[Peter206]

For what is good have extra VRAM ?

 

[Dulith1118]

maxing out games...Like to have every single setting maxed out and have good fps.. to play in high resolution like 2k if u have a separate monitor

 

[Peter206]

maxing out games...Like to have every single setting maxed out and have good fps.. to play in high resolution like 2k if u have a separate monitor

if i don`t want play on seperate monitor than is enough 4gm ? its not big difference if i will play only on laptop?

 

[Dulith1118]

nope 4gb should be enough actually...

 

[Peter206]

My experiences have been that ASUS has been top notch quality while I've always had problems with MSI products.

As for specs on these laptops, the MSI is a bit confusing. The listing says 512gb SSD, yet in the "tech specs" it says 128gb SSD, so it's unclear what they are actually selling.

Both listings contradict themselves for RAM, the listing says 32gb (for both), yet again, the "tech specs" says "Maximum Internal Memory" is 8gb...

Are you sure that website is a reputable retailer?

First sorry i didn`t want to put your post for bad , that was because i was on tablet
And i didn`t buy anythink from there yet, so i'am not sure if is good retailer.
Do you have any idea where should i buy ?
I'am found same model of this laptops on other shop , and they looks different
MSI GT72S 6QE-044UK http/www.dabs.ie/products/msi-gt72s-6qe-044uk-i7-6820hk-2x8gb-2x128ssd-gtx980m-8gb-17-3--9s7-178211-044-BNN4.html?q=MSI%20GT72S%206QE-044UK&src=16
Asus G752VY-T7049T http/www.dabs.ie/products/asus-g752vy-t7049t-i7-6820hk-32gb-1tb-512gb-ssd-gtx980-17-3--win10-with-headset--mouse-and-bag-g752vy-t7049t-BP8B.html?catid=15025&src=3

 

[Peter206]

nope 4gb should be enough actually...

So do you think Asusu should be better choice?

 

[Dulith1118]

Well according to u yes....

 

[Peter206]

what do you think about this ? https/www.overclockers.co.uk/asus-rog-g752vy-t7049t-17.3-g-sync-fhd-ips-intel-i7-6820hk-nvidia-gtx980m-8gb-gddr5-gaming-laptop-lt-231-as.html

 

[Martell1977]

I'am found same model of this laptops on other shop , and they looks different
MSI GT72S 6QE-044UK http/www.dabs.ie/products/msi-gt72s-6qe-044uk-i7-6820hk-2x8gb-2x128ssd-gtx980m-8gb-17-3--9s7-178211-044-BNN4.html?q=MSI%20GT72S%206QE-044UK&src=16
Asus G752VY-T7049T http/www.dabs.ie/products/asus-g752vy-t7049t-i7-6820hk-32gb-1tb-512gb-ssd-gtx980-17-3--win10-with-headset--mouse-and-bag-g752vy-t7049t-BP8B.html?catid=15025&src=3

Just a different shell, but this looks more legit. The specs are clear and make sense. The ASUS has 32gb RAM and the MSI 16gb installed. The ASUS has a 512gb SSD and the MSI has 2x 128gb SSD's in RAID 4.

Personally, I'd go with the ASUS from these links. It's a higher price but the listing is at least complete and clear.

 

[Dulith1118]

it's the same model with 8gb vram right??

 

[Peter206]

I'am found same model of this laptops on other shop , and they looks different
MSI GT72S 6QE-044UK http/www.dabs.ie/products/msi-gt72s-6qe-044uk-i7-6820hk-2x8gb-2x128ssd-gtx980m-8gb-17-3--9s7-178211-044-BNN4.html?q=MSI%20GT72S%206QE-044UK&src=16
Asus G752VY-T7049T http/www.dabs.ie/products/asus-g752vy-t7049t-i7-6820hk-32gb-1tb-512gb-ssd-gtx980-17-3--win10-with-headset--mouse-and-bag-g752vy-t7049t-BP8B.html?catid=15025&src=3

Just a different shell, but this looks more legit. The specs are clear and make sense. The ASUS has 32gb RAM and the MSI 16gb installed. The ASUS has a 512gb SSD and the MSI has 2x 128gb SSD's in RAID 4.

Personally, I'd go with the ASUS from these links. It's a higher price but the listing is at least complete and clear.

I just don't know about gtx if is 4 or 8gb in DABS.IE
and what do you think about this https/www.overclockers.co.uk/asus-rog-g752vy-t7049t-17.3-g-sync-fhd-ips-intel-i7-6820hk-nvidia-gtx980m-8gb-gddr5-gaming-laptop-lt-231-as.html it's look same like in dabs.ie but they put there how much vram is there.

 

[Martell1977]

it's the same model with 8gb vram right??

Same model, one doesn't list how much VRAM it has while the other does. It looks like the prices are in different currencies so I don't know how the prices compare. If the one from dabs.ie comes out cheaper (after taxes and shipping), you could always call them before ordering and confirm what it has. Considering they have the same part number, I'd think the VRAM will be the same.

 

[Peter206]

it's the same model with 8gb vram right??

Same model, one doesn't list how much VRAM it has while the other does. It looks like the prices are in different currencies so I don't know how the prices compare. If the one from dabs.ie comes out cheaper (after taxes and shipping), you could always call them before ordering and confirm what it has. Considering they have the same part number, I'd think the VRAM will be the same.

Thank's for help . I will go for Asus