Student Looking for sub 700 laptop for gaming

[qzyxya]

Hi guys, this is my first post here on tomshardware, so sorry if I mess anything up.
--------

I'm looking for a laptop for school that I can also use for gaming and video/photo editing with adobe after effects/premiere pro and photoshop. At the moment, I play TF2 mostly on my desktop along with a bit of battlefield and some assassin's creed and portal.

Budget: under $700 but i can extend it to $8-900 if its worth it

I'll definitely need a dedicated GPU and a moderately fast GPU. The screen size should be 14-15 inches, so that I can fit it in a backpack everyday for school. I also need good build quality (preferably not plastic) since slamming it in a backpack with heavy textbooks is not exactly gentle.

Here are a few different models I've picked out. I'd like some feedback on what you guys think would be good or bad, or for you to suggest another model or something

HP DV6z with A10 or A8 and 7730m

HP DV6z with A8/A10 and 7670m crossfire

Acer V3 571g with 3rd gen i3 and GT630m

Acer V3 561g with 3rd gen i5 and GT630m

Lenovo Y480 with 3rd gen quad i7 and GT640m LE. I've heard a lot of bad about this one. The gpu supposedly is underclocked and has only 96 shaders versus 364 or 398 or whatever. This is supposed to be a cheap reskin of the old gt555m.

Lenovo z585 with A8 and integrated 7660m (supposed to preform moderately well, best of the integrated gpus) very good build quality so i hear. extremely cheap $500 with a10 and 7660m

Lenovo Y580 with 3rd gen i7 and GTx660m - most expensive and i don't know if its worth it. Will it be that much of an upgrade? I might play games like skyrim or other graphics intensive games in the future

Acer M5 ultrabook 3rd gen i5 and gt640m (actual 300+ shader version so i hear)
------


Is it worth it to get intel i5 versus i3 in the Acer V3?
Is the 7730 or 7670m crossfire better for general use and gaming (the games i listed earlier)?
Is the A10 worth it over the A8?
How do the GT630m in the acer V3 and the GT640m le in the lenovo y480 and the acer M5 compare?
How far behind does the integrated 7660 by itself trail?
-------

I'm inclined to get the Y480 since its only 599.99 at newegg right now, but Im discouraged by the negative talk of the GPU. Could someone clarify if its that bad? Like would it be worse than the others in the price range? The i7 i assume will be very good for rendering in after effects and premiere, but if the graphics are worse than say the 630m or the 7670 then I won't get it.

Please just give me a recommendation of whats the best deal with good build quality in my price range.
----


EDIT:
I've read a couple other posts about the 7730m vs the 7670m and the a8 vs a10 but I'd like for someone to tell me how these will affect the gameplay (of my games, TF2 and BF3 mostly mayby skyrim) and everyday performance

 

[thor220]

You mean the $621 one post above right?(only lenovo i could find on the page) That is a build your own program, so I cannot comment on that. But he said $621 is the base price, so that seems quite high.

On your other question, the Toshiba does have a better battery(6hrs vs 4.5hrs). It also has a larger hard drive, more ram(6gb vs 4gb), a blu-ray player, HD Sound, one more usb 3.0 port, and built in blue-tooth.

Also just found this laptop: $674.99 base price
http/www.toshibadirect.com/td/b2c/cdetland.to?poid=2000037628&src=EXPL&cm_mmc=explore-_-bto_sku-_-satellite-_-S850

Has an even better graphics card but you will sacrifice some hard drive space and the blu-ray player. This is still pretty awesome with that graphics card though.

 

[qzyxya]

lol whoops forgot to link it again
http/www.amazon.com/Lenovo-IdeaPad-261729U-15-6-Inch-Laptop/dp/B0082PS2IM/ref=sr_1_1?s=electronics&ie=UTF8&qid=1349926595&sr=1-1&keywords=lenovo+z585+a10-4600
its got really good build quality according to reviews (all metal basically) has a A10 7660m and is only $512.

I have another question tho, will the 540m run faster overall since it has an i7? The acer on tigerdirect that is. The 540m 630m and 7660m are apparently around the same performance. Would the i7 on the old 540m be better than a newer i3? better than the a10?

 

[thor220]

Wow that's a great deal with the lenovo laptop. You do sacrifice a bit but That's better than the other one I suggest with price in mind. I would now have to recommend that over the other Toshiba a10. For that price, I would get the lenovo.

 

[thor220]

Well programs that run on ram will see increase performance with the i10 but because most laptops have a 5400 rpm hard drive, you would not see a great increase in desktop productivity. So spending less and getting the newer i3 would be a good idea because of the lower power use and new instructions.

 

[qzyxya]

1. First of all, here is an overview of your options under 1000$:
http/www.gaminglaptopsjunky.com/gaming-laptops-under-1000/
and under 800$:
http/www.gaminglaptopsjunky.com/gaming-laptops-under-800/
600$
http/www.gaminglaptopsjunky.com/gaming-laptops-under-600/
and 500$:
http/www.gaminglaptopsjunky.com/gaming-laptops-under-500/

2. I don't understand what you need - you were at the 700$ zone and than got to 500$

3. specific games?

4. The 7660G is very close in performance to the GT 540M / 630M even when they are coupled with an I7. For 500$ it's a good deal because you also get extra features - 750GB HDD and 6GB DDR3 + you get probably higher battery performance.

Yeah my max budget is the 700 ish dollar range, but if a 500 dollar laptop preforms just as well I'll get that. Specific games will be battlefield 3, cod 3, some source games (portal 2, tf2), possible skyrim later (would be fine with it on low)

Is it worth it to buy a $700-800 dollar laptop over these $500 with the 7660m?

thanks those lists are pretty useful on that site you linked gaminglaptopsjunky

 

[Wisecracker]

Do you have an OEM copy of Win7 available ?

Snag a HP Pavilion dv6z-7000 with the AMD Quad-Core A10-4600M Accelerated Processor & 1GB AMD Radeon(TM) HD 7670M discreet graphics for $600

Pop a 128GB SSD in that sucker and reinstall the OS using the HP laptop key -- put the original laptop HDD inside an external Vantec USB3 enclosure.

You're jammin' for less than $700, total.

 

[qzyxya]

For 700-800$ you'll get these advantages:
1. Higher performance
2. good fhd screen - better than the 768p ones:
http/www.gaminglaptopsjunky.com/768p-vs-1080p-screens-what-do-i-care/

But you have to decide if you want the performance and / or the fhd screen.

For 600$ you'll also get higher performance, but no fhd.
For 700$ you can get the dv6z-7000 with good matte fhd screen and good performance (but better wait for another coupon)
For 800$ you can get the QAL51-HD and if you can install Windows from your own copy and pay cash it will be perfrect under 800$

For medium settings on BF3, for example, , you don't need 800$, but 600$. So it's your choice

okay thanks i think i'll go to a store and try out fhd vs the 768 vs 1600x900. Maybe on a 14 inch scren the 768 resolution would be better. I think 1080p 15 inch might be overkill for me, but i'll see. thanks.

 

[qzyxya]

Than ks a lot. Is there a way to add karma or something on this site? I'm a total noob here.

 

[qzyxya]

actually could someone tell me how the GT640m LE in the 599.99 Y480 will preform? I really like that one's size and build quality (768x1336 14 inch is pretty good resolution and its also lightweight)

 

[thor220]

The Lenovo you picked a few posts back was a great deal at the price, why not get that?
http/www.amazon.com/Lenovo-IdeaPad-261729U-15-6-Inch-Laptop/dp/B0082PS2IM/ref=sr_1_1?s=electronics&ie=UTF8&qid=1349926595&sr=1-1&keywords=lenovo+z585+a10-4600

Of course your going to get a few perks by paying $100 to $200 more but the graphics on that laptop are great for the price and it's from a good company.

Also, the GT640m LE is slower than the a10 on the lenovo.

source: http/www.notebookcheck.net/NVIDIA-GeForce-GT-640M-LE.72199.0.html

 

[qzyxya]

The Lenovo you picked a few posts back was a great deal at the price, why not get that?
http/www.amazon.com/Lenovo-IdeaPad-261729U-15-6-Inch-Laptop/dp/B0082PS2IM/ref=sr_1_1?s=electronics&ie=UTF8&qid=1349926595&sr=1-1&keywords=lenovo+z585+a10-4600

Of course your going to get a few perks by paying $100 to $200 more but the graphics on that laptop are great for the price and it's from a good company.

Also, the GT640m LE is slower than the a10 on the lenovo.

source: http/www.notebookcheck.net/NVIDIA-GeForce-GT-640M-LE.72199.0.html

Wow really the 96 shader 640m is worse than the 7660m? Should i get that lenovo with the A10 for $512 or the HP DV6z with a better gpu like the 7670m?
Actually that makes sense, cause the notebookcheck page says its got like 300 shaders.

however, it might be more heavy and it is a 15.6 vs the 14 inch.

 

[thor220]

You many be right junky77, because certain OEMs cheap out on certain parts. This creates a lesser part or bottleneck, so I would not be surprised if the GT 640m could reach those speeds. But also note that AMD's new trinity just came out not to long ago and has excellent power management and is built on piledriver. According to Tom's, it translates into good overclocking.

source: http/www.tomshardware.com/reviews/a10-5800k-trinity-efficiency,3315-4.html

Also I would go with the A10 lenovo. It's integrated graphics are about on par with the HP's discrete one, and it does so using less power. Although I do have a thing against HP laptops. I have had to repair so many already in college, it's crazy. Not to mention, I was annoyed by all the bloatware that popped up during start-up. Just my two cents

 

[palladin9479]

Wow really the 96 shader 640m is worse than the 7660m? Should i get that lenovo with the A10 for $512 or the HP DV6z with a better gpu like the 7670m?
Actually that makes sense, cause the notebookcheck page says its got like 300 shaders.

however, it might be more heavy and it is a 15.6 vs the 14 inch.

Go with the HP DV6z-7000 model. I have a HP DV6z with the Llano GPU (3550MX) and a 7690M, absolutely amazing notebook for it's price. And yes the 1920x1080 screen is amazing though it raises the cost of the notebook by $150 USD. I personally feel the cost is worth it. Also look into getting a 7200RPM drive as a minimum, HP's SSD's are way overpriced and if you want one you should add it later. Finially make absolutely sure you get 8GB (or more) of DDR3-1600 as 2 DIMMs, memory performance it critical to the APU's graphics ability.

On a side note. I used to hate HP's as they were constantly having issues stemming from cheap manufacture. In the past couple of years they've done a complete turn around and their current crop of laptops are amazing quality. I was very hesitant to purchase my first DV6z for the GF (1366x768 3530MX) but was absolutely shocked when I saw how nice it was. It convinced me to get one of my own (DV6z 1920x1080 3550MX) to replace my 19 inch Sony for traveling / working. I use this notebook primarily for when I have to travel to another city on work and live out of a hotel room. Its small enough that it's not killing my back anymore yet provides more then enough performance to game and do various tasks from the hotel room / airport / ect. As a student I think your looking for a cheap notebook that can do light to moderate gaming while being small due to space constraints. The HP DV6z should suit you perfectly.

 

[palladin9479]

Something I forgot to mention, be sure to check the memory interface on any dGPU you buy. Many of these dGPU's can use DDR3 or GDDR5 memory. STAY AWAY from the ones using DDR3 memory, that includes nearly every GT 640M. The 640M with DDR3 has absolute crap performance, same deal with the 7730M. The 7670 / 7690 both use GDDR5 so you should be set with those.

 

[thor220]

Thanks for the heads up palladin9479. HP DV6z should be your first choice then

 

[palladin9479]

Let me do some research on the dGPU inside the HP DV6z, they might be doing something sneaky. 7670M can come with either DDR3 or GDDR5, where as my 7690M can only come with GDD5 memory. DDR3 for graphics memory is horrible even if it's at 900Mhz (1800 speed). In which case go with whatever configuration gives you a GDDR5 equiped dGPU.

 

[qzyxya]

so if i get the DV6z should i get the 7670m or 7730m>? im confused weather its gddr3 or gddr5. i dont think many laptops in the price range have gddr5

 

[qzyxya]

Yeah on amazon the only cheap laptop with dedicated GDDR5 was the acer timeline u m5 which looks pretty good actually for $700. It's got a 14 inch screen, the gddr5 version of the 640m le, and an i5. Could someone else link me to a better laptop with GDDR5 if they find one? Also im still wondering if the HP without gddr5 will be good. thanks

 

[qzyxya]

http/www.amazon.com/Acer-TimelineU-M5-481TG-6814-14-Inch-Ultrabook/dp/B0085H65VS/ref=sr_1_22?s=pc&ie=UTF8&qid=1350049448&sr=1-22&keywords=gddr5+laptop

 

[Wisecracker]

In a dual-graphics set-up with Trinity, you are likely better off with the DDR3 ---- stand-alone desktop discreet the other way.

Don't forget your SSD. That's the best performance upgrade you can make (laptop 5400 RPM drives ain't real high-flyers)