Tablets, Ereaders Signaling the End of Physical Books?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the Tom's Guide community: where nearly two million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Status
Not open for further replies.
[citation][nom]millerm84[/nom]Actually you can check out ebooks at most libraries. Everyone seems bent on not being able to resale or purchase used books, but I ask how many of you got a free edition of the entire works of Plato, Dickens, Verne, Poe like my wife did this year? At best you would still have to pay a buck or two for used copies of these free out of copyright e-books. Ereaders have some downfalls but I think the upside is well worth it. As far as some Apocalypse ending electricity and society as we know it with books being our only source of information, do you really think libraries will survive if power plants don't?Tom's has a strange following some are hellbent on getting bleeding edge tech while others cling to keeping things the same. I like the feel of a book in my hands for reading, I also like my wife's e-reader tons of free books/games, acts as a MP3 player, and limited web connectivity no paperback does that for me.[/citation]
yes and when the battery in your ereader dies what then?
can't use them on a plane as they will tell you electronic devices interfere with a planes instrument readings. what about those days where you don't have power, any one in the snow or hurricane belt will understand this.
books are old school, your child can't delete them or download tons of them while pushing buttons trying play games like angry birds.
when is the last time you plugged in a book and it over volted and destroyed the book? when is the last time a books OS got a virus or it's drive or CPU failed? your entire library is gone.
sure books rot and can be burned, they also don't suffer from glare and have to be read in the dark, they can be read any time, anywhere. i also typically get them in a size that isn't 7"-10"
digital copy has a great many advantages, you can get it changed to any language immediately, the tombs of volumes can be transported significantly more easily, anywhere and is immediately available provided you have a working machine with enough power and aren't outside in the sun or on a plane or in the hospital or getting an MRI. acquiring new books can happen at the touch of a button and a few moments wait but it's only a few seconds faster then using my credit card at a book store.
i'm not sure how an ereader would handle magnetism, but i'd keep it away from children and their toys with magnets like the thomas trains with magnet hitches, or the magna-doodle and such. i also do not know how well they would handle being read near a campfire or fireplace or in a hot or humid climate like brasil, a desert, or any place with fog snow or rain, i do not know how well they would handle the cold either but i know a great many people will leave them in their vehicles which are subject to great temperature swings. in the northern states and canada -50ºF is typical every year and in the summer temp will go as high as 200ºF in your vehicle. i already know this is not good for computer type electronics and cd players that aren't factory built as several of them died after being subjected to such conditions while being powered up in those conditions before i even turn the vehicle on.
ereading material should be supplemental and be supplied in the jacket of a book you purchase or available to d/l with a code from the book serial#
i do think ereaders are great as they will cut down on the trees being wasted to print news papers and magazines and other pamphlets and work documents.
i will never give up purchasing books and due to my fondness for water, books can be wiped off and dried off how ever ereaders can not, fish prove this every time some one gets into my boat 😛
 
[citation][nom]f-14[/nom]yes and when the battery in your ereader dies what then?can't use them on a plane as they will tell you electronic devices interfere with a planes instrument readings. what about those days where you don't have power, any one in the snow or hurricane belt will understand this.books are old school, your child can't delete them or download tons of them while pushing buttons trying play games like angry birds.when is the last time you plugged in a book and it over volted and destroyed the book? when is the last time a books OS got a virus or it's drive or CPU failed? your entire library is gone.sure books rot and can be burned, they also don't suffer from glare and have to be read in the dark, they can be read any time, anywhere. i also typically get them in a size that isn't 7"-10"digital copy has a great many advantages, you can get it changed to any language immediately, the tombs of volumes can be transported significantly more easily, anywhere and is immediately available provided you have a working machine with enough power and aren't outside in the sun or on a plane or in the hospital or getting an MRI. acquiring new books can happen at the touch of a button and a few moments wait but it's only a few seconds faster then using my credit card at a book store.i'm not sure how an ereader would handle magnetism, but i'd keep it away from children and their toys with magnets like the thomas trains with magnet hitches, or the magna-doodle and such. i also do not know how well they would handle being read near a campfire or fireplace or in a hot or humid climate like brasil, a desert, or any place with fog snow or rain, i do not know how well they would handle the cold either but i know a great many people will leave them in their vehicles which are subject to great temperature swings. in the northern states and canada -50ºF is typical every year and in the summer temp will go as high as 200ºF in your vehicle. i already know this is not good for computer type electronics and cd players that aren't factory built as several of them died after being subjected to such conditions while being powered up in those conditions before i even turn the vehicle on.ereading material should be supplemental and be supplied in the jacket of a book you purchase or available to d/l with a code from the book serial#i do think ereaders are great as they will cut down on the trees being wasted to print news papers and magazines and other pamphlets and work documents.i will never give up purchasing books and due to my fondness for water, books can be wiped off and dried off how ever ereaders can not, fish prove this every time some one gets into my boat[/citation]

All good reasons why cell phones will never catch on...
 
I don't buy hardcover books anymore. E-reader is the only way to go. I do believe that online book stores are going to have to get a lot better though. Right now I still go to bookstores to browse, and sometimes buy books there. This is because online book stores make little or no sense and I can never find what I want.
 
The same question can be applied to Compact Disks replacing vinyl records. Commercial audio CDs and CD players go back to 1982 and we can still buy a record player and used records. Look at the dark ages and how texts were being preserved by monks. It would take a thousand years to wipe out book reading and only if an efficient and systematic approach is implemented. Can you imagine any governmental entity actually working efficiently enough to implement such a book elimination program.
 
[citation][nom]willwayne[/nom]Maybe we will see a resurgence in finely-crafted leatherbound collector books? Low-volume, high profit is the last refuge of the physical book.[/citation]
adding to that that modern books uses self-degrading acid compound
 
As much as I love technology, it also kind of makes me cringe.

Internet killed the music stores being able to distribute music online. (Think of how many music stores your state had 10 to 15 years ago, and now hardpressed to see or need one now-a-days). Multiply that by the amount of employees in each store losing jobs. The people who made CD's. The people who distributed them (Drivers). The sales people to get them sold in stores...

Then books. Foresters, less work. Papermill, less work. Printing presses, less work. Shippers, less work... jobs lost again.

Then Post Offices. Hell, all ya need now is Fed-Ex or UPS as email has dominated.

I'm no activist, but makes me wonder, when are we going to print our clothes on a clothes printer and just eat bio-paste while generating our own power. Sounds cool, but pretty soon, internet will rule all.
 
[citation][nom]dfusco[/nom]Bunch of reactionaries here ahem...to address a few concerns:1 - If civilization collapses, trust me. you will have far more pressing matters on your mind than your book of the month club.2- E-readers will get cheaper and cheaper until in a few years they will almost give them away.3 - You will be able to check e-books out of libraries. heck, you can now.[/citation]

if you've ever been in a position where you're without power for an extended period time books are very good fallback item to have. Let's assume you and the world does come, for the first couple of months yea you'll have better things to do. But after you get settled in, get a food source and a water source, you'll quickly run out of things to stave off boredom and that's where books coming. Granted I don't believe that crap but oh well.

The reader will get cheaper and cheaper, but they won't be of quality. Look at the current cheap kindles, they're not even as good as the previous generation.

There are many books I want to check out from the library that are for adults and aren't information books. Most books are in the public domain I could download online for free.

[citation][nom]panders4[/nom]I wonder if people made a fuss about moving from engravings in stone and metal to paper? No! paper will never last! What if a civilization collapses? How will anyone ever know if everything burns or erodes!? We'll be doomed!I'm sure paper will still be used for art and collecting, just like engravings. Some people think print books are nice and will collect them. However, printing is already too burdensome for daily news and periodicals. Top seller books and encyclopedias are following.[/citation]

just like all the past civilizations collapsed and left nothing behind…
encyclopedias are going digital because it costs a lot to make them, people don't buy those kind of books in bulk so the cost of the book goes up. Going digital would just allow them to sell just the information not all the necessary printing. Newspapers are also digital just because it is a huge huge amount of paper to the newspaper. Considering information newspapers are usually out of date before they even get to the people, TV news is already reported on or before the newspapers out, or it's been online before either of those two sources got that information.

[citation][nom]loomis86[/nom]I wish I had a million bucks. I'd save bookstores if I did, and get even richer in the process. All it takes is an automated book printing and binding shop. If you want a paper book, just place your order via smartphone or internet connection and it goes into the shop and presto, a freshly printed book for you to read in an hour or less. All books will be printed in the same form factor and same paper. No hardback books. No color pictures.No books to stock...except maybe a 5 copies each of the best seller list. everything else is made to order.[/citation]

if only it was that easy to print the book.

[citation][nom]dfusco[/nom]All good reasons why cell phones will never catch on...[/citation]

they never caught on with me, then again I don't like talking to people.

---------------------------------------

the only reason I buy digital anything is because it's cheaper than the physical counterpart. If I can get the physical counterpart in the digital, as much if not more than the physical I have very little qualms with pirating it. I won't pay $50 for videogame digitally, I won't pay $1.50 for a drm free song, and I sure as hell won't pay as much if not more in some cases than a physical copy for book.
 
Oh puh-leeease.

Remember those big black vinyl records? Remember how they got replaced by cassette tapes, then CDs and eventually by MP3 players?

Remember those big heavy stones? Remember how they got replaced by cattle skins, paper and then by e-books?

Remember Betamax? VHS? Netflix? Youtube?

PAPER IS DEAD TO ME! But then again, I'm not over the age of 45...

Oh, the same thing is happening with video games, btw. PSP Go, PS Vita? Hmmm... Steam? PSN?
 
Real books more convenient unless you need to take a portable library with you. Plus losing a cheap paper book stings less than losing a $100 electronic device.
 
[citation][nom]alidan[/nom].The reader will get cheaper and cheaper, but they won't be of quality. Look at the current cheap kindles, they're not even as good as the previous generation.[/citation]

I disagree. The screen on the new Kindle is quite a bit crisper, sharper and easier to read than even the one produced a year ago. I have one of each and the Kindle Touch is superior. It is true that costs have come down, but this is due in large part to advertising on the Kindle. You can pay a higher price for one without the advertising, but since you don't see it when you are reading, I can live with it.
 
All points that I've read up to this point are quite valid arguments both for and against e-readers. Some of us want that instant gratification and portability that a e-book provides, whilst others (myself included) prefer to have the more tactile feel of the actual book. I can see both the advantages and disadvantages of both books and digital devices.

Having had to use an e-book for a couple of classes I had I prefer to have an actual paper version since to me it was much easier to use and find info I needed. To me e-books and other digital devices like TomTom are making us lazy, how many of you actually know how to read a map? How many rely on GPS or online maps to find your way around? How many of you actually went out and interacted with a physical person when you bought something?

I have nothing against technology and its convenience, and for some it is a necessity to be able to interact with the outside world due to some physical impairment. But all this convenience comes with a price...we are forgetting how to interact with each other, here we can all hide behind a fictitious name. All one has to do is look at the trolls/fan-boys/fan-girls on any forum.

Any way back to the story I do see paper based media going the way of the dodo eventually. This cannot be avoided it's a natural evolution of the way we get out media. Cave paintings -> clay tablets -> stone tablets -> papyrus, animal skins -> paper, hand written books -> Gutenberg press, books -> modern printing press -> movies, records, cassette, VHS/beta-max, CD, DVD, B-RD -> digital downloads. Like all those technologies from the past e-readers are still evolving, I just haven't found one that I like anymore then the rest in this category of devices. I'll stick to my paper books and physical media for the time being.
 
[citation][nom]dfusco[/nom]Bunch of reactionaries here ahem...to address a few concerns:1 - If civilization collapses, trust me. you will have far more pressing matters on your mind than your book of the month club.2- E-readers will get cheaper and cheaper until in a few years they will almost give them away.3 - You will be able to check e-books out of libraries. heck, you can now.[/citation]

The works of literature we have today were not given to us through e-Readers and digital media. Shakespeare didn't write his plays on a computer and Mark Twain didn't have an iPad to type on. I'm okay with this whole fad and craze of reading on tablets and such but old fashioned paper and pencil will never go away.
 
e-reader has certain advantages; like searching for a specific part or character in a book.
But it will always be a cold and impersonal method of reading. More suitable for tech books etc. than say, Tom Sawyer or some adventure novel.

 
Paper, whether it's a newspaper or a novel, is more fun and more accessible. If you want to flip over to the a certain section in the paper, it is quick and easy. Besides, I like the feel of paper.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.