Apple's Forstall Let Go for Refusing to Apologize for Maps

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the Tom's Guide community: where nearly two million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Status
Not open for further replies.

ta152h

Distinguished
Apr 1, 2009
297
0
18,930
[citation][nom]Teramedia[/nom]@cracklint is partly right. While Forstall may or may not have signed off on shipment readiness, Cook still had the ultimate decision to say "go" or "no go". He said "go", and then followed it up with an apology to users. Not quite the same as what Jobs would have done, but at least he acknowledged that there is a shortcoming in their product that they need to fix. If Forstall said, "We're not ready yet" and they forced him to ship anyway, then the problem lies with Cook. If Forsall said, "Yes, we're ready! Ship this puppy!" then like it or not, he deserves the boot.[/citation]

It's true, if people complained, Jobs would have advised the users "You didn't turn right", leaving them confused whether he meant correctly, or the opposite of 'left'.
 

zak_mckraken

Distinguished
Jan 16, 2004
868
0
18,930
[citation][nom]Teramedia[/nom]@cracklint is partly right. While Forstall may or may not have signed off on shipment readiness, Cook still had the ultimate decision to say "go" or "no go". He said "go", and then followed it up with an apology to users. Not quite the same as what Jobs would have done, but at least he acknowledged that there is a shortcoming in their product that they need to fix. If Forstall said, "We're not ready yet" and they forced him to ship anyway, then the problem lies with Cook. If Forsall said, "Yes, we're ready! Ship this puppy!" then like it or not, he deserves the boot.[/citation]
I agree, but Apple was ready to ship the iPhone, which include iOS6, which included Maps. Maybe Forstall told them the product wasn't ready to go live, maybe he didn't. Either way, Apple had 3 options : delay the iPhone, remove Maps from iOS6 or ship an half-assed product. Delaying a product was out of question, removing Maps could have been an option, but since it was a selling point of iOS6, they went for option 3 and now they're looking for a scapegoat. Typical corporate decision.
 

slicedtoad

Distinguished
Mar 29, 2011
72
0
18,580
The new map app is actually kinda cool (compared to anything else apple has released). It's glitchy and needs to be fixed, but it looks amazing aesthetically. And the glitches shouldn't be that hard to fix, they're largely database problems.

Anyway, I'm an Android user so my hope is that the apple map app will prompt google into updating their maps in a similar fashion. It's incredibly fun to navigate in full, beautifully rendered 3d (when it works).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.