The d-pad on the 360 controller is absolute crap. I actually had to buy a 2nd controller for fighting games like Street Fighter 4 and so forth because it is so inaccurate. I even tried the pringles lid trick, which did help, but not enough.In my opinion, I think the Xbox 360 Controller should take the spot for the best overall, I owned an Xbox 360 for 5 years before i moved to the PS3 (more friends played it) I hated the PS3 controller and it took me quite a while to get used to, the 360 controller had the perfect design for comfort and buttons. But when i got my hands on an Xbox One controller i was disgusted, the weird blocky/curved feel, the triggers are spongy as hell compared the the 360 controller, and who ever had any gripe with the d-pad on the 360? The entire controller all-around is a major step back from the 360 controller. So in my opinion the Xbox 360 controller should win best overall. Also the PS4 controller has to be hands down most comfortable controller to this day i that i have handled.