Archived from groups: alt.video.ptv.tivo (
More info?)
On Fri, 15 Jul 2005 19:18:45 GMT, "DanR" <dhr22@sorrynospm.com>
wrote:
>OT somewhat but has anyone read up on the DVR capabilities of "Media Centers"
>from computers makers such as Sony and HP?
Most, if not all, of the offerings from HP and Sony run Windows
XP Media Center Edition. Probably all are on the 2005 version by
now. You can probably find some detailed product specifications
on their sites or at Microsoft's site.
>Do they have TV program guides? (what service?)
Yup. Windows MCE gets its program guide info from zap2it.com.
But you don't even need to know that. It just downloads it all
automatically after you enter your zip code and pick your
provider and setup, much like the guided setup of TiVo. And
there is no fee for program guide info.
>Do they do TIVO-like DVR
>tricks... like use dual tuners... buffer....
Win MCE buffers live TV, supports dual tuners, lets you program
individual recordings or record a series - all the usual DVR
tricks. The one thing TiVo has that MCE doesn't is the wishlist
function.
>record 2 shows and playback 1 at
>the same time...?
If you have a dual tuner system and XP MCE 2005. Not all XP MCE
2005 systems come with dual tuners.
>Are they compatible with DirecTV in the sense they can record
>the digital stream? Or are they more like stand alone TIVOs?
Like someone else already mentioned, they do not record the
digital stream. If you have set top boxes you have to plug the
analog video outputs of the boxes into the video inputs on the
tuner cards, and use a serial cable or IR blaster to allow MCE to
change channels on the STBs.
Now that I've written several paragraphs that sound like a
product advertisement for MCE, let me list the big thing I have
against it. Reliability. In all the years I've had TiVo it has
only failed to record a show 3 times where I couldn't explain it
away for some reason beyond their control like a power outage or
a ball game delaying a show. The MCE systems I have are no where
near that reliable. I just don't trust them to record the
important can't miss shows. So basically I use them for a
backup to the TiVo and to resolve recording conflicts the TiVo
can't handle.