Archived from groups: alt.video.ptv.replaytv (
More info?)
Tony D <nospam@nospam.com> shaped the electrons to say:
>Why a Tivo cheerleader would post to a Replay forum is beyond me. But be
Anyone who doesn't spout the party line is a TiVo cheerleader to you,
I've been watching you for a while. So easy to dismiss any arguments
you don't like that way, isn't it?
I read a LOT of DVR related groups, mailing lists, etc. I'm
interested in the market overall. And I even answer questions for
users since I know a fair bit about a number of different products,
TiVo or not. I'm not so small minded that I only want to read about
products I use.
>And your assessment of Tivo's finances vs DNNA is hilarious. Like I also
>said, don't list your theories, call a broker.
My assessment? I see you also lack any reading comprehension. Did
you notice how I said your post was full of FUD (you know what that
is, right? Fear, Uncertainty, and Doubt - a common scare tactic used
by those with no real arguments) and 'no better than' the posts about
RTV going out of business?
Anyone would reading comprehension would understand that I think
*both* posts are FUD.
Let me spell it out to you so you understand.
I think your posts about the potential Tivo/Netflex deal (which is
just an industry rumor, I'd note) are pure FUD. Complete bullshit
without any supporting facts. How can there be supporting facts when
*neither* Netflix nor TiVo have made any announcements and the
comments amount to 'no comment'. Everything at this point is
spectulation by industry reporters with 'inside sources'. So when you
post about exhorbinant prices, etc, you're pulling it out of your ass.
In the same vein posts about how RTV is going to go out of business
are silly too. I do believe that DNNA is pulling out of the
standalone DVR business. That market is getting crowded and, frankly,
RTV lost the war for that market years ago. The margins are being
squeezed hard and even TiVo is moving to branch out of the pure DVR
market with integrated devices like DVD recorders, which analysts
agree are the next big growth market. Many years ago SonicBlue
announced their intention to product an RTV/DVD-RW box - but that
never came to be.
DNNA appears to have decided to abandon the standalone market to
pursue integrated media servers with DVR features. Not an
unreasonable move, the margins in that market are MUCH higher and it
is a new area without a lot of competition. I was at CES2004 and I
saw their product, it looked interesting - if a bit pricey. It hasn't
shipped yet, but I'm sure it will.
I doubt DNNA is going to fold up, as some have tried to indicate. I
do think that 'ReplayTV' as a standalong DVR is probably on its last
legs. After the buyout DNNA dropped features then in development,
like MP3 support and USB WiFi support, and they haven't updated the HW
at all. Apparently not even a manufacturing respin to use newer
components and reduce costs. There was one major SW bump for the 5500
release which dropped Send Show and Commercial Advance and added
Show|Nav.
You like to spread FUD about TiVo and call people 'TiVo cheerleaders',
I like to actually intelligently discuss facts.
What you're doing is the same thing as the people who FUD about RTV
that you like to slam. Maybe you should look in the mirror.
-MZ, RHCE #806199299900541, ex-CISSP #3762
--
<URL:mailto:megazoneatmegazone.org> Gweep, Discordian, Author, Engineer, me.
"A little nonsense now and then, is relished by the wisest men" 508-755-4098
<URL:http
/www.megazone.org/> <URL:http
/www.eyrie-productions.com/> Eris