Archived from groups: alt.video.satellite.mpeg-dvb,alt.tv.tech.hdtv (
More info?)
On Fri, 28 Jan 2005, Bob Miller wrote:
> The only country successfully broadcasting HD in the world? More like the
> only country unsuccessfully broadcasting HD. I would argue that Australia and
> Japan are both more successfully broadcasting HD using COFDM.
Once again, Bob Miller spews forth complete nonsense. The man is a
pathological liar, a con artist, and a scoundrel.
I have personally witnessed the over-the-air digital HDTV situation in
Japan, and they are YEARS behind the US in over-the-air digital HDTV
deployment.
The digital HDTV broadcasts in Tokyo do not even cover all of Tokyo. The
coverage area is about a 5 mile radius from the transmitting tower. Even
within that radius, HDTV receivers take a couple of seconds before they
lock on the signal, and the signal periodically pixellates.
Contrary to Psycho Bob Miller's assertations that COFDM digital TV can be
received using indoor "rabbit ears", rooftop yagi antennas are required to
receive Tokyo's OTV HDTV signal...assuming that you are within the service
area. It says so right on the specifications, and every salesman that I
talked to agrees.
Also contrary to Psycho Bob's assertations, every shop was in agreement
that handheld battery powered COFDM digital TVs were at least two years in
the future.
Psycho Bob prefers to rely upon marketing hype of "to be released"
products, and ignores the small detail that such vaporware often proves to
be nothing more than vapor. Non-functioning mockups and experimental
prototypes do not constitute products on the market.
What Japan DOES have is analog HDTV and analog SD widescreen. Quite a bit
of Japanese TV programming is widescreen. We skipped that entire
generation of technology and went directly to digital for widescreen.
Furthermore, Japan also has much more HDTV satellite programming; most
satellite service in Japan is HDTV. Almost all HDTV users in Japan have
satellite. Very few watch OTA HDTV; it's considered to be "experimental"
and not particularly interesting because satellite has more choices.
Also, there are only a couple of channels. It's like OTA HDTV in the US
about 6 years ago.
But Psycho Bob Miller (who admits to posting with his daughter's account
to get around being banned on AVSFORUM) would have you believe that
millions of Japanese are watching OTA HDTV and abandoning satellite en
masse.
-- Mark --
http/staff.washington.edu/mrc
Science does not emerge from voting, party politics, or public debate.
Si vis pacem, para bellum.