i think i would go for yamaha myself . onkyo and sony and pioneer ALL have one issue or another , there are reviews written by people who bought them on amazon.com . pioneer has a few models that have issues with the hdmi portion of the receiver , onkyo is/has become a lousy company , and i never have been to fond of onkyo . you said you were thinking birthday present , maybe a gift card or cash for something would be good. another thing that a lot of people don't think of is the company does not allways have to honor the warranty if you don't buy from an authorized dealer . what is an authorized dealer ? i am not sure . but i am sure that many of the internet stores aren't .