Powerdirector 16 Versions

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the Tom's Guide community: where nearly two million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Sidebar Sidebar
D

DefinitelyNotTom

Prominent
Jul 20, 2017
62
0
580
Looks like ultimate pretty much just adds some effects and templates. I'd "rather" get it than ultra, but the ultra version is almost constantly on sale for around $40, whereas ultimate is usually $100 for an actual disc version.

Just wondering if it's really worth getting ultimate...

No way am I going to pay a monthly fee to use the adobe program or pay the high cost of vegas pro. Then most other software either doesn't let you burn to BR, charges you extra to do so, is missing key features, or is slow. So I've about settled on powerdirector.

Also, judging by recent years, 17 is probably releasing in a few months, but when I asked them about it, they are making me register an account just to read their email answer. lol. So i'll probably not bother with that.

Anyway, so ultimate necessary or not? Recently newegg even had the combo of ultra and cyberlink's photo editor for $45 or $55 combined! Maybe should have just done that.
 
Sort by date Sort by votes


How do you feel about them? Especially both adobe elements programs and videostudio? (and powerdirector, as I guess whatever version you have will be close to the current one.).

I wish I knew of some products that come with the software because Imy luck is I'll buy the software and then buy a proiduct that unknowingly comes with it. :)
 
Upvote 0 Downvote


yes, I had read about those and about everything else. I don't remember why I weeded various ones out, but I came down to only a few I am considering. I think with resolve it was due to some locked features and for hitfilm it was because I saw multiple people say it's mostly for effects and that it isn't as good as other programs for other aspects of editing. Also, I need ability to burn to blu-ray, which I don't "think" those include, but I don't remember for sure.

I also thought about the stripped down version of vegas pro (I think it's called movie studio?), but everywhere I read had powerdirector and videostudio as the main two that don't cost hundreds. With powerdirector faster by a lot and videostudio costing for BR authoring.

Really the "main" thing I care about is edit options unrelated to effects. zoom and maybe motion tracking. But I don't want to go too low on features in case later I need some more features.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote


I don't have a version of PowerDirector. I used it when I was teaching so the software was left with the school. I'm partial to Adobe since I've used it for quite some time. If you want a photo editor as well there is the Premiere and Photoshop Elements bundle. Could be wrong but I think Corel will sometimes do a video and photo editing bundle.

Usually the software included with a camcorder is a limited version of the full product.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote

I will look into them again, but does elements even have the choice to burn to BR or to other file types, as well.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
You can export to DVD and various file formats.
From Adobe help:
"With each new release of Adobe Premiere Elements, Adobe reviews industry standards, market trends, and user feedback to define the new feature set in Premiere Elements 2018, support for Blu-ray and AVCHD disc burning has been removed. You can still export in H264 AVCHD and H264 Blu-ray..."

Source: https://helpx.adobe.com/premiere-elements/using/sharing-dvd-or-blu-ray.html
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
What's depressing is apparently no video or photo software is any good. Not any, at all, has a great overall rating on places such as Amazon. The 2018 elements ones are rated especially low, with people saying they made changes that were bad decisions. And as far as photo editing, both paintshop pro and elements are rated poorly there, barely over a 3/5. cyberlink's photodirector is actually rated better, but in expert reviews they rate elements and paintshop pro as good ones...

I may end up just using a free photo editor. But fore video editing I'd probably want more functionality than a free one would have. But I'm all over the place because I feel like if I get cyberlink's product and it doesn't allow utilization of the rx 580 then I just wasted hundreds on the gpu since I don't game.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
Paintshop Pro for photo editing, "rated poorly" ?

Not!!

I use that daily. Have used it since it was JASC and PSP v4 (or earlier).

Does it have ALL the bells and whistles of full blown Photoshop? No.
But so what. Unless this is a paid gig and your company is paying for that expensive PS license...PSP, or PS Elements, does just fine.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote


On Amazon it is. Both the ultimate version and standard one are rated barely over a 3. Normally, even barely good products are rated over a 4 on there. So a lot of people must having issues. And there's really no photo editing OR video editing rated above a 4 there, that I recall, except the very expensive ones costing several hundred.

Could be extra picky reviewers, who knows, but why would it be picky users only for software when everything else on Amazon gets 4+ reviews?
 
Upvote 0 Downvote


User reviews on Amazon are worse than useless.

https://www.amazon.com/Corel-PaintShop-Ultimate-Multi-cam-Software/product-reviews/B073XPYJT6
Of the 1 Star reviews...
"Very difficult to figure out. I may need to take classes to learn how to use it."
"This program was incredibly difficult to use and did not interact well with my computer, drawing tablet, or any of my artistic tools."
"Very confusing on download. no instruction. Do not want this item at all. very sorry I purchased this."
"Junk, will not work right with wndows 10,"
"I have used a trail of this program and loved it. I bought thos black Friday because it was alot cheaper so I am getting ready to get new computers in a couple months but I really need to use the program now so I called Corel to make sure it wasnt a one time use and was told I can only use the serial number 3 times"

--------------------------------------------
You really need to read what is behind those ratings.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
yes, but every product has those types of reviews and still are rated a 4+. Every one of these photo editors and video editors are rated below that. The elements video one for sure had a lot of bad reviews based on content of the product. If you look at that, it's review after review of low scores.

Most people who rate anything 1 star are ridiculous, but still all of this type of software is rated especially poorly on there.

Some of those you just showed have legitimate points, too. If it has issues working in windows 10, that is a problem.

Speaking of bad reviews, I got a good laugh reading A Wrinkle In Time reviews on IMDB yesterday.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote


Because it is complex software with a lot of features.
People are idiots.

Adobe Illustrator CC - 2.5 stars
Adobe Lightroom CC - 1.5 stars
Adobe Creative Cloud (Photoshop, Illustrator, Premier Pro) - 3 stars

Idiots.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote


well, that was my thought is it was just people too lazy to figure out features. But for the video editing elements, in aprticular, someone said they made major changes for the 2018 version, which are not good. I haven't read many of the reviews on the photo editors yet.

Have you used both paintshop and the adobe elements one for photo editing? I always feel like adobe is the most popular, but paintshop does get good reviews too.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote


Yes. I've used both Elements and PSP. And also Lightroom.
Currently, my workflow is Lightroom for primary photo editing, and then PSP for artistic effects. I do this almost every day.

I don't ned nor want full blown Photoshop. PSP and/or Elements, plus Lightroom, is fine for my usage.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
But why do you usually go to PSP over elements? Is it just personal preference on the feel of the software or is there actual features you like more in it? I'm only getting one or the other, or maybe nothing. I don't gain anything financially from any of this, just for fun. Although, i do make apps and so creating images could help me spice those up I guess...
 
Upvote 0 Downvote


Just personal preference.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
I agree that you cannot trust the ratings from Amazon and other etailers as well. Every program has its shortcomings and none are perfect. People will give a low rating simply because they don't understand how to or won't take the time to learn how to use the software. Most have trial versions you can download and try for 30 days. Try different ones until you find one you like
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
Problem with trial versions is my current pc would be a nightmare testing those on. It's an AThlon II cpu and 4gb RAM and had already had problems where it suddenly makes all kinds of noise when trying to do multiple things at once. And I haven't built my replacement, due to deciding between amd and intel for the cpu still, so I can't really test it in a meaningful way.

Another thing that sucks is this... adobe products are better with an intel cpu, but most other brands' video editors would be better with amd ryzen. Then some programs are good with nvidea gpu and some are better with amd there, as well. it's a big headache figuring this stuff out.

Anything I get, surely would feel insanely better than my current specs... Usually even my current pc feels fast, though, it just gets annoyingly slow when multitasking.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

M
  • Question Question
Question Purchase advice needed when I replace my Samsung Galaxy S21 Ultra in a Future Upgrade
Replies
2
Views
7K
Android Smartphones
scarlettm59
S
I
  • Locked
  • Solved
Solved! Samsung Galaxy A11 swam, then repaired... now new issues... how do I tell if I was scammed?
Replies
7
Views
10K
Android Smartphones
COLGeek
COLGeek
S
  • Solved
Solved! Which Brand is currently on top? I am at a loss and confused...
Replies
1
Views
2K
Laptop General Discussion
hang-the-9
hang-the-9
M
  • Solved
Solved! Different versions of Office 365 apps being installed ?
Replies
4
Views
16K
Apps General Discussion
captaincharisma
captaincharisma
H
  • Locked
  • Question Question
Question Shocked at Tom's Guide...supported by users but only looking after themselves?
Replies
9
Views
11K
Forum Feedback
COLGeek
COLGeek

TRENDING THREADS

Share this page

COMPANY
RESOURCES
FOLLOW
Top Bottom