Think the hypocritical thing is a red herring - so what if it's hypocritical of her, it's still wrong to pirate music - there's no such thing as a free you know what and it's not OK to take sh*t that doesn't belong to you. How do people argue about the most basic rules of civilized society? So Lily Allen (who had at least two decent songs IMHO) posted music online without really thinking about what she was doing and then others illegally downloaded it. I don't know that she didn't pay for the music that she made her mixes out of, and even if she didn't, it's not against the law to make a mix tape of your friends' music. Of course it is against the law to distribute those mixtapes but distribution requires a party at both ends. I think Lilly Allen was acting like what she is: a young woman. Young men and women swap mix tapes. Woopty doo. Still, the law's the law - she should face the same that other "I didn't know any better" defendants, i.e. a nice fine, one that surely she can pay.