Yarrick, thank you for explaining exactly why I feel it is a good review. Because it's not done by someone like us, who's used one of these since they were made by Belkin, but instead by someone who knows precious little about it beyond that it has a relatively steep learning curve, and is useless for much beyond MMO gaming. I agree that they probably could have done more research, but niche peripherals are always more miss than hit when it comes to the reviewers having the slightest clue what they're reviewing when it's something esoteric something that got chucked at them.
Also, the Nostromo 2 would be the reworked version offered by Razer; while it wasn't entirely an upgrade, it was at least a lot less clunky to use than the Belkin version, and the panel with the D-Pad has (in my experience at least) less of a tendency to work loose... if only less, not none.