[citation][nom]AndrewMD[/nom]I hate when people bring up the cost of XBOX Live service. Get over it. You wouldn't buy a 360 even if Microsoft reduced or made the service free.[/citation]
I would. My brother already has both so I don't need to choose, but I think if either of us had to live with just one, we'd choose PS3, and if I ever moved out on my own and wanted to buy either one, I'd buy PS3 simply because it's a much better value.
Now back to Natal. I've said it before, and I'll say it again. It's a glorified EyeToy, and major game designers who aren't getting paid to spin Microsoft BS would agree with me. I wouldn't have a problem with Natal, but it annoys me that people say it will be a Wii killer and that it will work with almost any 360 game. There are too many functions that are necessary for a game that a camera can't emulate. Which means whatever you saw in that horrible Jimmy Fallon tech demo is all you'll be able to do with it. It's just Microsoft's desperate attempt to convert uneducated Wii owners and other casual gamers. And like I said, I wouldn't have a problem with it if they didn't misrepresent their product.
At best, it will be a fun toy to show off to friends, but the novelty will wear off. Kind of like when people get webcams with the different backgrounds and overlays and turn themselves into werewolves and stuff. It's fun and funny for about 5 minutes.