• Happy holidays, folks! Thanks to each and every one of you for being part of the Tom's Guiide community!

Which Laptop is better overall?

Platinum Era

Honorable
Jul 22, 2013
21
0
10,560
I have been looking for a laptop to replace my aging Samsung R522. I have selected 2 that like:

http://www.futureshop.ca/en-CA/product/acer-acer-aspire-v7-15-6-ultrabook-gunmetal-intel-core-i5-3337u-24gb-ssd-500gb-hdd-12gb-windows-8-v7-581-6489/10254572.aspx?path=226359e5ff9e81e3595821eea0ca4579en02&SearchPageIndex=1

or

http://www.futureshop.ca/en-CA/product/asus-asus-r405cb-14-1-laptop-black-intel-core-i5-3337u-750gb-hdd-8gb-ram-windows-8-r405cb-fb51-cb/10256770.aspx?path=668e4849c241528be776cbc69a135632en02&SearchPageIndex=1

I will be using the laptop for general students purposes (Mostly MS office) and entertainment (Youtube, movies). I might do some gaming but I do have pretty powerful desktop for that exact purpose (4670k, GTX 770).

Now I like the Asus because of the GT 740m and faster RAM (8GB DDR3 SDRAM at 1600mhz). I dislike that it's a 14.1" laptop.

I like the Acer because it's an "Ultrabook" (it's behind Intel's most of Intel's requirements) and comes with a SSD boot drive (I believe), it is thinner and is a 15.6" Laptop. The Acer on the other hand has 12GB SODIMM DDR3 at 1066mhz and it has the HD 4000 chip. It also looks like it will come with a lot of bloatware

They both have identical CPUs (i5-3337u), identical battery life (5ish hours) and they will both be on sale for 599.99 as of Friday, August 23rd

I dislike that both laptop have such a weak resolution of 1366x768.

Which would you guys recommend?

Now I can easily wait another couple of months for more Haswells to pop up (the Pentiumns and i3s) or for the Ivy-bridges to receive even larger price cuts.

*And if any of you would like to recommend a different laptop, it has to be from Futureshop.ca/Bestbuy.ca (I want to use a gift card I have instead of my money, the gift card was won in a contest)



 

pyro226

Distinguished
Sep 22, 2011
28
0
18,590
Overall, the Asus laptop is better. If you think the screen size is going to be a problem, don't get either. Wait for something that better suits your needs to go on sale.

I really don't like that the Acer only has one memory slot and the slow memory speed. I personally wouldn't get the Acer. From what I've read (no windows 8 experience), Widnows 8 is pretty quick to boot up because the normal boot sequence resumes from a kernel hibernate from the previous power-off. It may read applications a bit faster with the SSD, but I think the SSD on these laptops more going to be a selling gimmick rather than a large performance benefit.