I totally think she is wrong and Match.com is not at fault.
If I were match.com, I would be hesitant to start down this path of feeling as though they are being proactive. A potential Match.com user should not place their private information (DOB, SSN Driver License #, etc) in the hands of a dating site for the following reasons;
1. The company will now possess more personal information and that could lead to a cyberattack. (as in the case Eclipse) Now they are on the hook for identity theft. (big lawsuit) Match.com employees would now have access to this information readily available to exploit. (lawsuit)
2. Persons convicted of violent attacks, drug crimes,not sex offenders are not filtered out. (lawsuit)
3. If the SO crime occurred because one person broke a statute that happened years ago maybe when they were minors or had no idea the other person was underage (as in the case of Lawrence Taylor and Rob Lowe) you prejudge a person before an explanation is allowed,. (lawsuit)
4. If I introduce a female to a person that had a violent history, am I now subject to a lawsuit?
Conclusion: This woman writes books and gives dating advice. Therefore you presume she is not a novice. She is a Harvard graduate. That presumes she is intelligent. She invited the male to her personal residence -what did she think should have occurred?
Lastly, Match.com did not give this women permission or encourage her to take this man home.