... wtf are these comments?
I bought my first apple product, the iPhone 3GS a few days ago. I used to have the AT&T tilt and I loved it. I decided on the iphone because I'll be moving out of my house soon, and will be traveling a lot and I wanted access to the internet (buying internet access for my apartment would be a waste, as I will only be there when I sleep). iPhone was the cheapest mobile internet connection I could get in my area, and heck, mobile phone and I could get texting.
Never having used itouch, ipod, iphone etc (but having used wifi with my AT&T Tilt, which is slow and not very reliable... even using 802.11) my experience has been nothing less than eye opening. I even got my dad playing with the phones google maps application and he hates cell phones and thinks the internet should go away.
Slow speeds? Maybe in your area or you are just jumping on the att-hate bandwagon. I can download apps, maps, and watch videos perfectly fine.
My only beef with AT&Ts iPhone service is that it is expensive. Considering the bill is for phone service AND internet service it's fairly typical of what I'd pay if I had bought both as separate services.
Also, AT&T gives discounts depending on where you work. I qualified for a 24.1% discount on my bill... never had verizon do that for me, just my 2 cents.