G
Guest
Guest
Archived from groups: alt.video.ptv.replaytv,alt.video.ptv.tivo (More info?)
"Randy S." <rswitt@NOSPAM.com> wrote in message
news:db9dub$9p6$1@spnode25.nerdc.ufl.edu...
> > CheezWiz wrote:
> >
> > Primarily their implementation of show sharing between units. I think
> > they went in the wrong direction there.
> > Replay's streaming functionality is much more useful. Of course, TIVO
> > implemented actual file downloads, so I cant say Replay beat them on
> > that..
>
> Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't believe MRV (moving shows
> between units) requires a fully transferred file to begin playing. You can
> play the show as soon as a minimal amount has transferred. And I do believe
> that most people's networks (including wireless) can transfer shows between
> units well beyond real-time rate, so once started you shouldn't have to wait
> at all. I believe the MRV transfers are quicker than TTG transfers because
> no decryption is required.
It depends on the network and the quality level of the recording. With "High"
quality recordings on my standalone (about 1.3 GB/hr) I can transfer the
recording fast enough that I can start watching it immediately and it gets far
enough ahead that I can actually skip commercials without waiting on the
transfer. With "High" quality recordings on my DVD-R unit (about 2.0 GB/hr) I
have to start the transfer a few minutes before I start watching to avoid a
delay. In no case do I ever have to wait for a transfer to finish before I
start watching.
Ken
"Randy S." <rswitt@NOSPAM.com> wrote in message
news:db9dub$9p6$1@spnode25.nerdc.ufl.edu...
> > CheezWiz wrote:
> >
> > Primarily their implementation of show sharing between units. I think
> > they went in the wrong direction there.
> > Replay's streaming functionality is much more useful. Of course, TIVO
> > implemented actual file downloads, so I cant say Replay beat them on
> > that..
>
> Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't believe MRV (moving shows
> between units) requires a fully transferred file to begin playing. You can
> play the show as soon as a minimal amount has transferred. And I do believe
> that most people's networks (including wireless) can transfer shows between
> units well beyond real-time rate, so once started you shouldn't have to wait
> at all. I believe the MRV transfers are quicker than TTG transfers because
> no decryption is required.
It depends on the network and the quality level of the recording. With "High"
quality recordings on my standalone (about 1.3 GB/hr) I can transfer the
recording fast enough that I can start watching it immediately and it gets far
enough ahead that I can actually skip commercials without waiting on the
transfer. With "High" quality recordings on my DVD-R unit (about 2.0 GB/hr) I
have to start the transfer a few minutes before I start watching to avoid a
delay. In no case do I ever have to wait for a transfer to finish before I
start watching.
Ken