LonelyMan :
Currently I do not have an AV, as I am trying to decide between Nod32, Kaspersky, Webroot and Emisoft and it is very hard. All my computers have limited accounts where I do my gaming and surfing and I have Malwarebytes free that does a scan once a week and never picks anything up. Also, Java does not exist on my computers.
If I were to pick between what you've listed, it would be a tie between Kaspersky and Webroot. The way I'd pick between the two is what kind of discount I can get on both. From the technical standpoint, I really don't think one should really be picked over the other (based on what I've see so far). I would simply shop around for a deal on both, and pick from there.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I'll also give you guys a little first impression of Qihoo 360, since I just go it up and running, and I tend to be harsh on AV software overall. First off, I should mention that I removed my previous AV software with
IObit Uninstaller; complete removal means you won't have anything left behind for your new software to deal with (like filter drivers, or inactive software junk to sift through). I also updated my drivers (IObit has a nice program for that too), and installed Qihoo's 360 Internet Security. I opted for the package deal, over the AV only, because I figured I'd see how much it bogged down my system. While download times from the website could have been much better, that was the slowest thing I've seen from it yet.
Qihoo 360 does have three virus engines (360 Cloud, QVM II, and Bitdefender), and it also tells you the last time each one was updated (instead of a blanket update time stamp); no complaints there. Running a quick scan yielded average speeds, though I wouldn't complain about that; I don't really see "slow" scan speeds that most people complain about, and I am running older hardware (2.2 Ghz Core2 Duo with 4 GB of memory). Will scan speeds possibly be slow for you? I would say that is based on what you have going on in the background. No complaints from me on scans, though; however, I will run a full scan later, and make note if it's lacking in speed. I did like how the scan was done, though. It showed me a nice 5 step explanation of what it's doing, which I found to be very idiot-proof, and it kind of served as a nice means of passive teaching for the user. I liked that, because it gets a little nerdy without making the user feel nerdy. I'd say a bonus point for being clever, and for one-upping all the other free software I've seen with it's descriptive scanning technique. I remember when I first started learning about the file systems/etc., and I I used to watch the scanned folders fly by on the screen, but never knew what they were a part of; 360 gives you a nice little peak as to what they are scanning, and includes the location string while it scans. Again, just a nerd moment of teaching that I liked, but I think that's a big selling point for newer users... damned clever, and very clean in presentation.
According to (what I would call) the Dashboard, which is a nice drop down style menu, you have three categories for protection: Computer Protection, Internet Protection, and Privacy Protection. Each category gives you an on/off slider for different protection means, and it keeps things very basic. I did notice some notable ones, though: USB protection, Anti Keylogger, and Webcam Protection. Those three are ones you normally wouldn't see (from my personal experience), or at least would be hidden somewhere in your settings. While I prefer not being able to turn these off (for entry-level beginners), it's nice for someone like me; I hate digging around advanced settings for a single file/false positive that I'm trying to run.
It does have a sub-par "cleaner," which I found to be severely lacking in comparison to Ccleaner. Ccleaner not only cleans out more junk, but it offers secure file deletion, and auto-detects which programs you have installed. 360 kind of looks slightly confusing, and also makes promises of certain program cleaning. I'd ignore the cleaner altogether, and opt for Ccleaner, or whatever your personal choice would be. It also offers a Sandbox, which I haven't tested it yet. I will do some relatively extensive horsing around with over the next week, though. I do like that you can turn on/off sandboxing, and you can add a "Run file from Sandbox" option to the right-click menu; so that's nice. For me, this works out well, as I'd prefer to choose to sandbox a potentially harmful install, instead of auto-sandboxing everything. I'll play around and see what happens.
I will be leaving the suite in my beloved DND mode (Do Not Disturb), so I won't be commenting on notifications/etc.. I also hate pop-up notifications as a whole, and prefer programs to be entirely self-contained. While I do miss out on a few things, I've always been willing to deal with that. But, back on track with the more important stuff...
It has relatively customisable 'Protection Settings', somewhat customisable scanning techniques, and even has a decent amount of live-protection options. I do wonder just how well this software works in each individual field, but it looks relatively promising for giving the user control; that makes me feel somewhat torn. For those that like changing the 'theme' that your software has, you can do that. Themes are a petty feature for most, but I think it's nice to have a uniform look with my OS, and other programs; but I'm also one of "those" guys. Overall, I'm kind of liking this suite... and I really don't say that often with security software (seriously
). First impressions yields a highly positive experience, but I will say that I expect it to fail somewhere; they
always do. I'm mostly hoping everything that's seen doesn't give off a false sense of security, as I've seen a lot of promises in the industry that are accompanied with a weak delivery. I do think the USB protection, Anti Keylogger, and Webcam Protection options are nice add-ons, but I'll see if I can find some extensive testing on this (might have to test it on my own to get a good review, but no promises on if I will actually resort to that). Qihoo does seem to promise a lot for their free software, and that makes me even more sceptical for quality. On the other hand, they do have relatively positive marks (thanks for bringing them up, spooky2th). While they don't have the highest ratings, the rating aren't very disappointing... and I do tend to say that your AV/security software
should be your last line of defence. Would I recommend them based on ratings alone? No.
I'll let you guys know what else I find out. This might earn a rare stamp of approval from me, or turn out to be a let down... we shall see.