Microsoft Wants Infected PCs Booted Offline

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the Tom's Guide community: where nearly two million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Status
Not open for further replies.

guzz46

Distinguished
Mar 1, 2010
81
0
18,580
As someone previously said the problem isn't with the internet, the problem is with Microsoft's poorly designed OS.
 

bluekoala

Distinguished
Feb 8, 2008
70
0
18,590
[citation][nom]otacon72[/nom]The only reason Linux is considered more "secure" is because nothing of importance runs on it. 95%+ of the World runs windows so where do you think a hacker is going to concentrate his time? Same thing with MacOS.[/citation]
Nothing of importance runs on Linux? Are you serious?!?
 

wolfseeker2828

Distinguished
Oct 29, 2007
35
0
18,580
The difference is medical viruses don't have a governing intelligence telling it who to infect and how. Computer viruses can be changed and redistributed in a matter of hours. Skilled hackers will always find a way around it - code is code.
 

alyoshka

Distinguished
Oct 2, 2009
576
0
19,010
Hey!!! Why don't they think of implementing Human Health Public Models correctly first.... then they can waste all that dough on internet health states.
 

demonhorde665

Distinguished
Jul 13, 2008
802
0
18,930
noy is this guy living in freaking lala land or what ?

sounds cherrry on paper, but seriously even if they could implement this you knwo teh nightmare this would cause to consumers , ther are millions of computers infected with viruses, that would trhow a system like this on alert not to forget bloat ware ,and crazy DRm Schemes that from time to time read as avirus (i actually had a freind whose norton kept tripping out on securom in bioshock and spore).

just crazy
 

Giovanni

Distinguished
Oct 17, 2008
5
0
18,510
The contract that I made with my ISP basically states that if my computer starts spewing half a million emails a day, they can and will disconnect it from the internet. Apparently they have had that policy since 1995, and it works very well, so I really don't understand why you all think that this somehow too hard to do.
 

uruquiora

Distinguished
Mar 19, 2010
30
0
18,580
[citation][nom]otacon72[/nom]The only reason Linux is considered more "secure" is because nothing of importance runs on it. 95%+ of the World runs windows so where do you think a hacker is going to concentrate his time? Same thing with MacOS.[/citation]

err.. that sounds like the speech of a 12year old guy only playing games and dowmloading movies on his pc... Ever heard about mission critical Busines Applications and Middleware Infrastructure ??
can't really see that as "nothing of importance"...
 

troger5troger5

Distinguished
Dec 7, 2009
8
0
18,510
sorry, just another way for the goverment to take control over something else. what new pictures of aliens, better turn off those computers before they spread the news.
 

zak_mckraken

Distinguished
Jan 16, 2004
868
0
18,930
It's actually a great idea and it wouldn't be that complicated to implent. Has it's been pointed out though, measures will have to be taken to eliminate false positives. Furthermore, a PC doesn't automatically have to be excluded from the net at the first sign infection. Threats could have levels on and only the highest level would require quarantine.
 

jabliese

Distinguished
Apr 25, 2006
108
0
18,630
If Microsoft wants to do this, they can build their own Internet.

How is Joe Average user going to get rid of an infection without Internet access, hmmm?
 
G

Guest

Guest
So, Microsoft just buys an antivirus company, and all the sudden we need his antivirus installed to access internet. Nice. I bet some goverments will like that excuse also.
I thing they are ways already to make some entrusted areas, if they want to define an internet.3.entrusted thats risky, but to close access to internet thats tooo much.
 

dark_lord69

Distinguished
Jun 6, 2006
740
0
19,010
I like the idea...
I guess ISP's would need to scan your computer for infections before you connect? OR prehaps they would require an active scanner that confirms to them that your PC is virus free by sending a message quick before connecting...
 

jgiron

Distinguished
Nov 11, 2008
134
0
18,630
ok, I got a virus how do I get it off my computer without the internet?

answer...you can't, even a fresh install requires updates which gives you the chance the virus to attack once again.
 

bhaberle

Distinguished
Nov 15, 2008
159
0
18,630
I do not care for this idea. Users will go online to download programs or instructions to remove a virus. So what will they do if they have no other computers to use? Get ripped off by GeekSquad?
 

Giovanni

Distinguished
Oct 17, 2008
5
0
18,510
[citation][nom]troger5troger5[/nom]sorry, just another way for the goverment to take control over something else. what new pictures of aliens, better turn off those computers before they spread the news.[/citation]
I think your aluminiun hat will keep you safe...
 

Giovanni

Distinguished
Oct 17, 2008
5
0
18,510
[citation][nom]dark_lord69[/nom]I like the idea...I guess ISP's would need to scan your computer for infections before you connect? OR prehaps they would require an active scanner that confirms to them that your PC is virus free by sending a message quick before connecting...[/citation]
No scanning involved, the whole idea is based on the fact that if you have a "harmfull" virus, it starts sendind shit into the world, and it is very easy to see where all the traffic is going, conspiracy theorist's need not apply, they really don't give a shit about your porn downloads...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.