I disagree with the above posts about something going wrong. Pilot training would just be textbook about what to do in emergency situations, something this guy could of easily read on his own. Its the simulator that he got his training from. A flight simulator can easily be made to simulate emergency situations, better then any textbook or paper training. He had the same level of access to training materials as a licensed pilot would of had.
Honestly he should of just taken the test and got his license, but who knows what paperwork / requirements were present.
I see situations like this all the time (paper vs experience) in the IT field. You have lots of guys that are cert monkeys, they do nothing but use testking.com to study the tests and get lots of paper under their belt. But when it comes time to actually ~do~ something they don't know what to do and are basically worthless, well not quite their good at getting coffee. Something the IT field is learning the hard way, experience > paper every time. Just HR likes papers cause their nice and neat and easy to quantify.