But is it harder than deciding on a second name because your first was already taken?
Sorry for the late reply, ended up being busy and forgot to check back.
Since we are well well over your $1000, I'll throw in another setup.
L/R - Ascend Acoustics Sierra 1with NrT upgrade ~$1200/pr
C - Ascend Acoustics Sierra Center with NrT upgrade ~$600
Rear - Ascend Acoustics CBM 170 SE ~$300/pr
Sub - 2 SVS PB-1000 ~$1000 (or one for $500)
Your choice of AVR
This will be better than either of the two choices you listed, and roughly equivalent in price. You'll lose out on the dipole rears of the PSB, but dipoles can really be hit or miss (same with bipoles). The prices are about what it is shipped, but you can try calling them and seeing if you could get a discount for ordering the 5 speakers.
I still pick the two subs because you can even out the bass throughout the room far better with multiple subs. If you need to keep the budget down, you can just go with one. I'll throw in another option too: Rythmik F12 which is also sold by Ascend, it's a servo sub which I like and it's priced ~$910 with 5% off if purchased with other speakers. I would definitely choose this sub over the B&W or PSB subs your listed.