Archived from groups: alt.video.ptv.tivo (
More info?)
On Mon, 14 Feb 2005 23:55:03 +0000, Jack Ak wrote:
> "Lenroc" <lenroc@NOSPAMFORYOU.hotmail.com> wrote:
>> No, certainly not when 30sec skip is _enabled_, but if it is _disabled_
>> (as the macro I posted ensures, assuming that 30sec skip is normally on),
>> 2xAdvance will get you to the beginning.[...]
>>
>> The only problem that I know of with the macro I posted is that it assumes
>> 30sec skip is always on (and would fail miserably otherwise).
>
> You macro cannot *ensure* 30 skip is on or off.
It can, as I stated, ensure 30 second skip is off, if and only if the mode
is already on.
> What happens in LiveTV mode and during FF and Rewind cannot be ignored.
LiveTV is irrelevant for a button to "rewind a recording to the
beginning".
> You recognize the problem. Two advance button presses will change
> current position to beginning *only* when playing a saved program with
> 30 sec skip disabled.
Which is why I suggest having the macro disable that mode before pressing
Advance...
> Your macro will fail because it cannot detect when 30 sec skip has been
> enabled.
It doesn't need to "detect" anything. For a remote macro, you can make
assumptions about what's normally true. If it was my remote, I'd set up an
unused button to toggle 30second skip (SPS30S). If the 'rewind' macro got
out of sync, I'd simply press the SPS30S macro button once, and, voila,
the rewind macro works again.
I admit it's not perfect, but it should work most of the time. When it
fails, none of the buttons being sent are likely to cause any problems.
If the OP is set on adding that functionality, I see my macro as the best
way advanced so far.
--
Lenroc