Geek Squad indeed sucks.
I have three stories to share concerning them.
The first encounter was when I was returning dvd I received and already owned. The return counter at my best buy is close to the Geek Squad counter so when I was waiting in line I saw the Geek squad girl scan a hard drive on a PC she was working on, first she copied all his music, then went through is pictures and was looking for movies and such when I asked her "When you find his passwords are you going to steal those too?" She gave me a sharp irritated look then turned the monitor away from me so I couldn't see it.
Second about a year and a half ago I was having an issue with my home system, I had it narrowed down to the PSU or the mother board. I didnt have a power supply tester and all the decent private pc repair shops were closed in my area so being elbow deep in taking components out of my PC I asked my wife to call Geek Squad to see if they had a tester. My wife had the guy on speaker phone and asked him directly if he had a PSU tester. The Geek Squad dunce said "Sure bring it in we can test it, it wont even take very long."
I took my PSU out and drove all the way down there, I held it up to the Geek Squad guy (the same guy who had answered the phone I recognized his voice). He looked at he power supply and asked "Whats that?" I looked at him incredulously and told him my wife had talked to him he had told us to bring it in I had heard him say it myself on speaker phone. His stuttering, stammering reply was "I meant for you to bring the whole PC in, I can test that." I told him, "you dont even know what a power supply is why would I give you a whole pc, I obviously know more that you."
The third was my wafe wated a new laptop, we researched it and best buy had a great deal on a compaq she wanted. Only the ones on the shelf were $70 more than the add. When i inquired I was tole they had been optimized by Geek Squad, when I asked what that meant I was told they get rid of bloat ware and make the PC run faster. I laughed in the sales guys face and said "you mean they charge $70 bucks to hit the delete button on a few programs and do a defrag (I didn't know at the time Win 7 defragged itself)? Please find me one that has not been ruined by Geek Squad." The guy gave me a funny look but did as I asked.
In other words Geek Squad is (at least the ones near my home) a groups of thieves who probably dont even know how to take the side panel off of a case. And they over charge for the simplest thing.
It does not surprise me to see them fleecing people over a PS3 firmware upgrade.